Hi,
I am looking for suggestions for an RC magazine.
My subscription to FLYRC is over and I am disinclined
to renew as it does not fit my needs. 80% of that magazine
is "reviews" which I view as advertisments.
I am looking for a magazine that has
1) few (or none) "reviews",
2) Provides good scale plans (not of ugly sticks)
3) Has detailed technical articles on all aspects of the hobby
4) Has more of a homebrew perspective
Thanking you in advance.
B Thomas
Paul McIntosh - 03 Jun 2004 20:09 GMT
There are none that have all of that. I think the best one out there for
honest writing is RC Report. RCM is nothing more than a Tower ad, IMHO. I
haven't seen a Model Airplane News in quite a while but they were looking
more like an ad magazine as well. You might want to look for a Scale RC
Modeler.
--
Paul McIntosh
http://www.rc-bearings.com
> Hi,
> I am looking for suggestions for an RC magazine.
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
> Thanking you in advance.
> B Thomas
Fred McClellan - 04 Jun 2004 07:11 GMT
>There are none that have all of that. I think the best one out there for
>honest writing is RC Report. RCM is nothing more than a Tower ad, IMHO. I
>haven't seen a Model Airplane News in quite a while but they were looking
>more like an ad magazine as well. You might want to look for a Scale RC
>Modeler.
The only SRCM you'll find will be in someone's archives.
That rag went belly up when the publisher tried stiffing the authors
for articles already published, me included.
Ask AMC what she thinks of Ed Schnepf.
Robert A. Plourde Jr. - 03 Jun 2004 20:36 GMT
I thnk RC Report is the closest you will find. Model Airplane News looks
just like FlyRC to me. Most of the reviews in FlyRC are so short. I guess,
they have to be short to stay within the short attention span of most of the
readers. I want more, in depth articles.
> Hi,
> I am looking for suggestions for an RC magazine.
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
> Thanking you in advance.
> B Thomas
James D Jones - 04 Jun 2004 20:10 GMT
This may be true, but "FlyRC" magazine seems to have at least twice as
many reviews as any of the others. They also seem to cover more current
topics. If you don't want to know about new products, or lots of ads
turn you off, then maybe Flying Models will be your cup of tea. They
tend to provide lots of construction articles. But, if you are into
only RC, "RC Report" may be indeed what you are looking for.
Jim - AMA 501383
> I thnk RC Report is the closest you will find. Model Airplane News
> looks just like FlyRC to me. Most of the reviews in FlyRC are so
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
>> technical articles on all aspects of the hobby 4) Has more of a
>> homebrew perspective
Red Scholefield - 03 Jun 2004 21:39 GMT
IMHO RC Report comes the closest for a domestic publication. R/C Model World
out of the UK (Traplet Publications http://www.rcmodelworld.com/) is one
fine magazine - much more technical detail.
Red S.
Brian Reynolds - 03 Jun 2004 23:50 GMT
>I am looking for suggestions for an RC magazine. My subscription to
>FLYRC is over and I am disinclined to renew as it does not fit my
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
>3) Has detailed technical articles on all aspects of the hobby
>4) Has more of a homebrew perspective
I like Flying Models.
1) It has a couple of reviews in each issue, but they are much more in
depth than anything I see in Fly RC, Model Airplane News or
Backyard Flyer. The July issue has the Sig Jenny and the Multiplex
Sonic Liner.
2) Recent (last five issues) scale plans include Steve Wittman's
Buster, Stabiloplan IV, Polikarpov I-16, Spitfire and Learjet 23.
That group includes rubber FF, electric RC and EDF. There were
other non-scale plans including those using glow or gas, CL and RC.
3) I haven't seen any other magazine (except the AMA one) that covers
as many bases as Flying Models. There are regular columns for Old
Timer, small models, C/L Combat and Stunt, electrics, FF, R/C
Pattern, and ducted fan/turbines. The only thing they don't do
regularly are helicopters and sailplanes (although the previous
issue has an article on last year's Midwest Slope Challenge).
4) The current issue has four plans based construction articles in
addition to the building information in the regular columns.

Signature
Brian Reynolds | "But in the new approach, as you know,
reynolds@panix.com | the important thing is to understand
http://www.panix.com/~reynolds/ | what you're doing rather than to get
NAR# 54438 | the right answer." -- Tom Lehrer
Mike Norton - 04 Jun 2004 01:01 GMT
> Hi,
> I am looking for suggestions for an RC magazine.
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
> Thanking you in advance.
> B Thomas
If you find one such, tell the group here!
At present, I don't subscribe to any RC mags.
-- Mike Norton
Mike R. - 04 Jun 2004 01:20 GMT
> Hi,
> I am looking for suggestions for an RC magazine.
> My subscription to FLYRC is over and I am disinclined
> to renew as it does not fit my needs. 80% of that magazine
> is "reviews" which I view as advertisments.
You have to understand that the company gives the mag the product
to review inwhich the company advertise there product in the
mag..........its the mags "bread and butter" $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
Then you buy the product with the great
review.....$$$$$$$$$$$$$.....out of your pocket. ;-)
Now everyone is a happy camper.....You,Mag,and Company
> I am looking for a magazine that has
> 1) few (or none) "reviews",
> 2) Provides good scale plans (not of ugly sticks)
> 3) Has detailed technical articles on all aspects of the hobby
> 4) Has more of a homebrew perspective
GOOD LUCK lol..........try Flying Scale Models: has plans and
homebrew perspectives
p.s. whats wrong with "sticks".......I love my GWS SS :-)
Mike
B Thomas - 04 Jun 2004 01:21 GMT
Thanks for the pointers guys.
I did check out the webpages for rcreports,rcmodelworld
and flyingmodels, and am working on making up my mind.
sincerely
b thomas
Fred McClellan - 04 Jun 2004 07:11 GMT
>Hi,
>I am looking for suggestions for an RC magazine.
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
>3) Has detailed technical articles on all aspects of the hobby
>4) Has more of a homebrew perspective
Such mags are far and few between, in the US.
My FlyRC "subscription" ended with the supposed complimentary copy.
Better by far are several of the Brit mags, namely RC Model World,
Flying Scale Models, RC Scale International, and Radio Control Models
and Electronics.
See the Traplet and Nexus web sites at http://www.traplethouse.com/
and http://www.modelflying.co.uk/pages/index.cgi .
Insofar as reviews is concerned, RC Report beats all the US rags hands
down. The Pizza Eater demands honest evaluations, and he gets 'em.
Pretty sure RC Report invented "Cheers" and "Jeers".
Been there, done that, the T-shirt still fits, and I hope Gordon
forgets I owe him an article on the 9Z 'cuz I _still_ don't have the
thing fingered out !