> Don't forget that Lloyd is well advanced in bringing out the DEB set
> probably later this year.
> Hopefully if Eureka is doing the 620 then there will be the variation of the
> windows & doors as compared to the one on the market already.
From talking to the various rtr principals it seems that having a kit
available makes very little difference to the number of rtr models sold.
It would seem that they are different markets.
So all you chaps (and chapettes) out there who are capable of
constructing a kit, congratulate yourselves, you can do something that
about 95% of the rtr market can't do.......
DPC James McInerney
STOP! In The Name Of The Lore!
At http://www.cia.com.au/bullack/ , homepage for "Lambing Flat"
my HO NSWGR branchline, includes information on the full size NSWGR.
http://www.cia.com.au/bullack/rvrtitle.html
for the "Rurr Valley Railway", my G gauge West Coast of Tasmania garden line
or http://members.optusnet.com.au/lambingflat/ for the family stuff!
Keith Norgrove - 28 May 2004 14:33 GMT
>> Don't forget that Lloyd is well advanced in bringing out the DEB set
>> probably later this year.
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> From talking to the various rtr principals it seems that having a kit
>available makes very little difference to the number of rtr models sold.
Quite, but having a good rtr available makes a big difference to the
number of kits sold.
Keith
Make friends in the hobby.
Visit <http://www.grovenor.dsl.pipex.com/>
Garratt photos for the big steam lovers.
> Don't forget that Lloyd is well advanced in bringing out the DEB set
> probably later this year.
> Hopefully if Eureka is doing the 620 then there will be the variation of the
> windows & doors as compared to the one on the market already.
Although the silhouette picture on the website is most likely a 620/720 set
perhaps it is just 'representative' of the fact there will be a railcar set
produced which may or may not be a 620/720. Given Lloyds already has the
620's and is also doing the 900's there's still an opening for the earlier
600/700 sets.
Some of the advantages of doing a 600/700 are:
1) The prototype was introduced earlier than the 620 and 900's so will be of
value to those modelling the early steam/diesel transition years.
2) Tuscan and Russet paint scheme (620's were introduced too late for this)
3) Those who already have the Lloyds 620 will be more likely to buy a 600
than another 620 (so more sales for Eureka as they'll be modelling something
that hasn't already been done).
Then again maybe we're all still wrong and Eureka are actually going to do
the "Silver City Comet" in its original form with Green and Cream livery.
Michael S.
John Dennis - 29 May 2004 07:42 GMT
>Although the silhouette picture on the website is most likely a 620/720 set
>perhaps it is just 'representative' of the fact there will be a railcar set
>produced which may or may not be a 620/720. Given Lloyds already has the
>620's and is also doing the 900's there's still an opening for the earlier
>600/700 sets.
...
>Then again maybe we're all still wrong and Eureka are actually going to do
>the "Silver City Comet" in its original form with Green and Cream livery.
I reckon it might be a 400 class. A single unit has some advantages,
and they certainly ran in the North West, which just happens to
somewhere not far from Werris Creek.
John
==========================================================
John Dennis jdennis@optusnet.com.au
Melbourne,Australia Home of the HOn30 Dutton Bay Tramway
and the Australian Narrow Gauge Web-Exhibition Gallery
Dutton Bay URL: http://members.optusnet.com.au/duttonbay
WebX http://members.optusnet.com.au/jdennis/ng_webex.html
dave richards - 30 May 2004 23:29 GMT
Chaps,
I agree with John it certainly does look like a 400 motor, but whatever it
is hopefully we can all support the current and future projects by any
manufacturer (if possible).
Cheers
--
Dave Richards
Locomotive Driver
Pacific national
Melbourne
> >Although the silhouette picture on the website is most likely a 620/720 set
> >perhaps it is just 'representative' of the fact there will be a railcar set
[quoted text clipped - 19 lines]
> Dutton Bay URL: http://members.optusnet.com.au/duttonbay
> WebX http://members.optusnet.com.au/jdennis/ng_webex.html
Bob & Lynda Harper - 31 May 2004 10:25 GMT
Of all the railmotors/rail cars that the shadow looks like, the only ones
that have that "round thing" on the top are the Deb sets and 620/720
cheers, guess we will all find out in time!
> Chaps,
> I agree with John it certainly does look like a 400 motor, but whatever it
[quoted text clipped - 36 lines]
> > Dutton Bay URL: http://members.optusnet.com.au/duttonbay
> > WebX http://members.optusnet.com.au/jdennis/ng_webex.html
werris - 31 May 2004 14:27 GMT
"Bob & Lynda Harper" wrote >
> cheers, guess we will all find out in time!
Yes and tomorrow might just be the time.
Werris
TRC - 29 May 2004 12:13 GMT
I'll stick to my guess of it being a 620/720 of the type with the larger (or
extra) doors and less windows on the power car which would make it different
to Lloyds version.
The 600/700 which was done in brass by Berg has a different roof profile to
the "Shadow".
I doubt it to be a DP (Silver City Comet) as there is too much tooling to do
in producing the rolling stock that goes with it & without the carriages I
doubt there would be many sales.
Again the idea of the "Shadow" being representative of a railmotor type car
could also indicate CHP38 also known as Creamy Kate. Then again as
suggested elsewhere it may equally be a 400 railmotor.
The argument of there being different markets of RTR to kits is true but
that distinction becomes blurred when Lloyd (and others) offer what were
kits in a RTR format.

Signature
Cheers
Terry C
> > Don't forget that Lloyd is well advanced in bringing out the DEB set
> > probably later this year.
[quoted text clipped - 20 lines]
>
> Michael S.
Poath Junction - 31 May 2004 04:20 GMT
The latest rumour (that I'm really just starting now) is that the proposed
model is indeed a 620/720 set, however in O Gauge. Given the current level
of interest in O gauge NSW/Australian modelling and the lack of any RTR
models this could just be the start of something "big" ;-)
Michael S.
William Whale - 29 May 2004 13:32 GMT
A single unit, rounded profile, with cowcatcher at each end...my money is
on a 400 railcar.
Put me down for one.
.......................................Bill
--
"I have not said this. I am not here". -The Navigator
> > Don't forget that Lloyd is well advanced in bringing out the DEB set
> > probably later this year.
[quoted text clipped - 23 lines]
>
> Michael S.
>Don't forget that Lloyd is well advanced in bringing out the DEB set
>probably later this year.
But NOT "ready to run".
Hunslet
TRC - 30 May 2004 07:34 GMT
You forget that Lloyd usually has his kits available as RTR
Just check his web page & you will see that nearly all his milky bar locos
are available almost continually in a RTR state.

Signature
Cheers
Terry C
> >Don't forget that Lloyd is well advanced in bringing out the DEB set
> >probably later this year.
>
> But NOT "ready to run".
>
> Hunslet