Newbie Gyro question
|
|
Thread rating:  |
GeeBeer - 24 Jul 2004 05:12 GMT Hello,
What are the differences between a heading hold gryo and a piezo gyro? Are there more kinds than that? As a first timer... what type of gyro would be a good preferable? If, for instance, I were go get a heading hold gryo... would that hinder me later on after I am doing more than just hovering?
I appreciate your comments!
Chris Ramakers - 24 Jul 2004 11:28 GMT A Heading Hold gyro is a big help for learning to hoover. For flying I set the gyro on normal.
Doubleheli
> Hello, > [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > > I appreciate your comments! Beav - 25 Jul 2004 22:55 GMT > A Heading Hold gyro is a big help for learning to hoover. > For flying I set the gyro on normal. Rather strange reply given that a heading hold gyro is all but essential if any kind of aggrssive (3D) flying is likely to be on the agenda.
 Signature Beav
Please note my E-mail address is "beavis dot original at ntlworld dot com" (with the obvious changes)
Beavisland now lives at www.beavisoriginal.co.uk
david - 24 Jul 2004 12:07 GMT > Hello, > > What are the differences between a heading hold gryo and a piezo gyro? You are confusing the ideas. Gyros are of two construction types - piezo and mechanical. All modern gyros are piezo.
Within the construction types there are two performance types, HH and Rate
HH gyros lock the tail (hence the head as well) and make it possible to, say, fly fst sideways with little trouble.
Rate gyros "simply" hold the tail from spinning under torque and so make flying a model chopper much, much easier.
Buy a piezo gyro (I doubt you could buy anything other) and buy a gyro that has two settings - rate AND HH.
Good luck
David
Are
> there more kinds than that? As a first timer... what type of gyro would be a > good preferable? If, for instance, I were go get a heading hold gryo... > would that hinder me later on after I am doing more than just hovering? > > I appreciate your comments! Steve R. - 24 Jul 2004 20:53 GMT > > Hello, > > [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > > David Can you still get a piezo gyro that's "not" HH (heading hold)? I haven't seen one in a "long" time. Fortunatly, mechanical gyros have gone the way of the dinosaur. May they rest in peace! ;-)
GeeBeer, definitely get a heading hold gyro from any of the major brands. That's Futaba, JR, CSM. There may be others but these are the one's I hear the most about. Personally, I like Futaba but see what the locals are flying. All of them will do the job.
Good luck & Fly Safe, Steve R.
Olaf Greck - 24 Jul 2004 13:49 GMT >Hello, > [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > >I appreciate your comments! http://runryder.com/helicopter/f44p1/ " Beginners Corner and Links"
they explain better than me,
best regards
Olaf
tippy - 24 Jul 2004 21:07 GMT I'd like to gain a little more knowledge while the thread is going.
I agree with the description of HH hold but only partially with the Rate description. I was under the impression that the Rate mode only limited the Rate ( I wondered why they called it that) the heli will yaw. That's why I agree with the description partially.
Under heavy torque, the yaw will be great but as the gyro senses yaw, it will simply dampen the rate at which the heli yaws . This limit is usually adustable.
My gyro does not "keep the heli from spinning" (in rate mode). It keeps the heli from spinning faster than my eye/hand can stay with it but it still spins.
As far as learning to hover, HH makes the process easier but you gotta learn how to control the heli at some point so be prepared to use a little Rate mode on occasion. It gives your left hand something to do besides move fore and aft :)
tippy
Steve R. - 25 Jul 2004 02:53 GMT Hi Tippy,
You're right in one thing, HH gyro or not, you still have to learn to "fly" the helicopter. Compared to the old mechanicals that a lot of us learned on, HH gyros are a God send but you still have to fly the machine. Hovering was not a problem but, in fact, it took me a while to get used to flying around with a HH gyro. The tail commands are different and it took a little getting used to. It wasn't a big deal, just different.
As for the "rate" part, I usually use the term "rate, command," this is how I generally describe it to people who ask.
When flying the gyro in HH mode, it's trying to do just that, hold heading. The gyro doesn't really "know" which way it's pointed. What it can do, however, is measure how much the model has turned and how fast. It can then apply a tail command to counter that movement and bring the machine back to where it was. All of this is predicated on the tail rotor having enough authority to do what is needed.
Back when we used mechanical gyros, we had to set the ATV's or travel adjustments in the transmitter so the tail rotor servo linkages didn't bind at the extremes. Actually, we'd deliberately set the system up to bind a "little" at the extremes on the bench. Once the helicopter was in flight, the gyro would naturally take a little bit of that back, because it couldn't tell if the turn was commanded by the pilot or not.
With HH gyros, the "gyro" controls the tail rotor servo, "not" the pilot. That's why you have to do a setup procedure with the gyro itself to set the servo ATV's or travel adjustments so that the tail rotor pitch controls don't bind at the extremes. This is "very" important especially with the new digital servos. If the servo binds at the extremes, it would draw a LOT of current off the battery, trying to force the linkage to a point that it's not capable of reaching. That's bad for the battery "and" the servo.
What about the "rate, command" part I mentioned above? The HH gyro will try to rotate the helicopter at a given rate in degrees/second based on how much tail command the pilot is giving from the transmitter. How fast the helicopter will rotate is dependant on how much tail rotor authority the model has, what the ATV's or travel adjustment settings are in the transmitter, and how far the pilot is holding the stick over. Assuming that tail rotor authority is a non issue, and it usually is in most of the models available these days, the higher the ATV's or travel adjustment settings are, the faster the model will spin for a given stick position being held by the pilot. If the tail control is too fast for the pilot, all he/she has to do is turn the ATV's or travel adjustments down on the tail rotor (rudder) channel in the transmitter. The gyro doesn't care if the ATV's or travel adjustments are set to 100% and the pilot is holding the stick 50% over, or the ATV's or travel adjustments are set at 50% and the pilot is holding stick "all" the way over. It's all the same to the gyro. The nice part of all of this is that the pilot can hold the stick at a certain point and the gyro will try to provide a given yaw rate regardless of what the wind is doing. With the old mechanical gyros, the pilot had to gradually (sometimes not so gradually) increase the tail command as the tail rotor pushes into the wind. Then, when the tail is pointing straight to the wind and crosses over to the "downwind" side, the pilot has to immediately reduce and sometimes reverse the tail rotor command to maintain the same yaw rate. It was difficult to perform a constant rotation rate pirouette in the wind. Now, with HH gyros, the gyro does all the work. It will apply whatever tail command is needed to maintain the "commanded" yaw rate regardless of whether or not the tail is pushing into the wind or being pushed by the wind. If that means taking the tail rotor to full control right, then full left, it'll do it, even though the pilot is only holding 1/4 stick over. That's what I meant when I said that the gyro controls the tail rotor servo and not the pilot.
One way to see this rate command phenomenon is to set the tail rotor ATV's or travel adjustments to a certain level, say 80%. Take the helicopter up (I'm assuming you're capable of doing this safely, or letting someone who is try this!) and give a full tail rotor command from the transmitter and note how fast it spins. Next, land and reset the tail rotor ATV's or travel adjustments to 40% and perform the same test. You'll see that it spins significantly slower than at the 80% level. That's what they mean by a "rate," or as I like to say, "rate, command" gyro. It's really cool as far as I'm concerned.
Hope this makes sense. Fly Safe, Steve R.
> I'd like to gain a little more knowledge while the thread is going. > [quoted text clipped - 17 lines] > > tippy david - 25 Jul 2004 19:12 GMT > My gyro does not "keep the heli from spinning" (in rate mode). It keeps the > heli from spinning faster than my eye/hand can stay with it but > it still spins. Then surely it's incorrectly set up? A standard rate gyro should enable you to hover the machine hands off, no tail yaw and certainly no spinning, shouldn't it?
I accept that if you fly the machine sideways etc it WILL then yaw, and it might even weather cock, but hovering into wind it should exhibit no motion at the tail that requires permanent rudder stick to be applied.
It should pirrouette well of course when you end-stop the stick!
Thats my understanding anyway. Its how mine work for me.
D
Beav - 25 Jul 2004 23:08 GMT > > My gyro does not "keep the heli from spinning" (in rate mode). It keeps > the [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > to hover the machine hands off, no tail yaw and certainly no spinning, > shouldn't it? I think you've grabbed the wrong end of the stick Dave. I suspect he means the heli will spin when he inputs a command, not when there ISN'T an input to spin.
> I accept that if you fly the machine sideways etc it WILL then yaw, and it > might even weather cock, but hovering into wind it should exhibit no motion > at the tail that requires permanent rudder stick to be applied. Correct, but like I say......
> It should pirrouette well of course when you end-stop the stick! Which is what I think Tippy meant. (I could be pissed up and wrong though
:-)) > > Thats my understanding anyway. Its how mine work for me. And me:-)
 Signature Beav
Please note my E-mail address is "beavis dot original at ntlworld dot com" (with the obvious changes)
Beavisland now lives at www.beavisoriginal.co.uk
Beav - 25 Jul 2004 23:03 GMT > Hello, > > What are the differences between a heading hold gryo and a piezo gyro? Heading hold gyros ARE piezo gyro's, although some of the less expensive piezo gyro's don't have the heading hold ability. Most heading hold gyro's can be switched between heading hold and the more conventional "rate" mode (Rate gyro's are non heading hold)
Are
> there more kinds than that? There used to be electro-mechanical gyro's but their days are long past now, so in reality, the answer is no.
As a first timer... what type of gyro would be a
> good preferable? A switchable piezo (heading hold/rate). Gyro's like the CSM 560, Futaba 401 (or better like the 600 series) andothers are the prefered choice these days.
If, for instance, I were go get a heading hold gryo...
> would that hinder me later on after I am doing more than just hovering? Not at all, although I would caution you about using heading hold for your first circuits. the wind over the tail end of the heli will do the job of keeping the tail behind the nose a LOT more efficiently that a haeding old gyro will (when it's in heading hold mode). this only really applies for the first few circuits while you get used to seeing the heli "flying" as opposed to sitting in a hover.
For those who eventually made/make the move to heading hold from the rate gyros, the very idea of going BACK to using rate mode is almost beyond a joke, but choosing a gyro that has both gives you the best of both worlds.
 Signature Beav
Please note my E-mail address is "beavis dot original at ntlworld dot com" (with the obvious changes)
Beavisland now lives at www.beavisoriginal.co.uk
|
|
|