Anyone got some advice on flying a r/c helicopter?
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Harry Strybos - 19 May 2009 07:34 GMT Hi All
I have bought a couple of R/C electric helicopters and finf them impossible to control. My helis:
Twister CP Gold Ninja 450 3D
When I try to fly either, they both take off in some inderterminate direction when they lift off.
While I could find this useful to trim a couple of trees in my yard, it seems to do the heli little good going through this exercise.
My anticiaption was that a heli (chopper) could be hovered with some level of control.
What am I missing?
Cheers
Harry
Nothome - 19 May 2009 12:03 GMT >What am I missing? Practice and experience perhaps. When first learning to hover a model helicopter it is not easy. After you have had a bit of practice you will wonder why it was so difficult in the beginning.
It also could be a bad setup on the helis. How much experience do you have at setting up a model helicopter ?
Tampa Bob
Harry Strybos - 20 May 2009 05:40 GMT >>What am I missing? > [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > > Tampa Bob Thanks Tampa Bob
My experience is zero. Most things I try I can work out over time, helis are a bit different.
sligoNoSPAMjoe@hotmail.com - 19 May 2009 14:30 GMT >Hi All > [quoted text clipped - 18 lines] > >Harry You picked two advanced machines. They will be difficult to master under the best of conditions.
Where are you trying to learn? I have a nice two car garage where I learned. Just a little bit of wind outside makes the difficult impossible for the new flyer.
I chose the the CX2 and it took me a while to get half way comfortable with it. It also cost a few replacement parts. With what you have, I would strongly suggest finding someone locally who has flown and mastered them to help you out.
Harry Strybos - 20 May 2009 05:44 GMT >>Hi All >> [quoted text clipped - 31 lines] > you have, I would strongly suggest finding someone locally who has > flown and mastered them to help you out. Thanks for your reply
What do you suggest as a good r/c (electric) helicopter for a beginnner like me?
BTW I also have a two car garage. Is this a good place?
Thanks
Harry
Nothome - 20 May 2009 11:51 GMT >BTW I also have a two car garage. Is this a good place?
>Harry Check out this web site, http://www.dream-models.com/eco/index.html for and excellent beginner tutorial for those with the indoor space to try it.
Harry, the kids and younger people in general usually have an easier time learning to hover a model heli. You should still be able to do it though, with extra effort.
I was sixty when I started learning how to fly helis. I told myself several times, " I guess I am too uncoordinated to fly these things." :) It finally came though. Now almost every time the heli spools up and lifts off I wonder "What in the world was so difficult about this back then ? Why did I have so much trouble ?" It just takes practice, lots of it at our ages.
Tampa Bob
Harry Strybos - 21 May 2009 06:26 GMT >>BTW I also have a two car garage. Is this a good place? > [quoted text clipped - 16 lines] > > Tampa Bob Thanks Tampa Bob
You have made me feel a whole lot better about this. Love to exchange some views with you.
My email address is harrystrybosAT<myisp>.com.au. Please replace AT with @ and <myisp> with optusnet
Thanks good buddy
Harry
Bruno - 21 May 2009 12:23 GMT On Wed, 20 May 2009 06:51:11 -0400, in rec.models.rc.helicopter you wrote:
> Check out this web site, http://www.dream-models.com/eco/index.html >for and excellent beginner tutorial for those with the indoor space to [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > > I was sixty when I started learning how to fly helis. I second Bob's suggestion to see Radd's method at the site above. I had a Walkera #4 fixed-pitch heli (that is considered a very, very poor-handling heli, next to impossible to control). Following Radd's method to the letter got me flying the thing in a couple of days.
After about a nonth playing with the #4, I decided I'd really get into RC helis, so I got an instructor and started taking lessons on his Raptor. It goes like this: instructor and pupil each have a transmitter, both interconnected by a cable, so the instructor can take over immediately if necessary, with no need to hand over the transmitter. After only TWO days, the instructor set me solo (no cable to another transmitter) on HIS Raptor.
That is how well Radd's method works.
Note that I'm not quite 60 just yet, but at 49 I'm no fast-learning kid either.
And... Harry, get all the info you can about the hobby. If there are no other flyers near you (or even if there are, really), join those two RC helicopter forums:
www.runryder.com www.helifreak.com
There are other, excellent forums, but those two are really, really good with very helpfull folks. To boot, Helifreak has tons of video tutorials on setting helis up. Very interesting & helpful stuff. You don't want to miss it.
sligoNoSPAMjoe@hotmail.com - 20 May 2009 15:19 GMT ><sligoNoSPAMjoe@hotmail.com> wrote in message ...
>> Where are you trying to learn? I have a nice two car garage >> where I learned. Just a little bit of wind outside makes the [quoted text clipped - 15 lines] > >Harry If I had it to do over, I would once again start with the CX2 and work with it inside my garage.
Kevin - 19 May 2009 15:50 GMT > Hi All > [quoted text clipped - 18 lines] > > Harry to fly a helicopter, 1,you need to be able to fly it before you can trim it 2 before you can fly it it needs to be trimmed sort of chicken and egg problem
my advise is 1,get some sort of flight sim even FMS & its free, this will help 2 put lots of practise on sim first 3,get some one to trim helicopter first then try, if no one is near you buy a more stable helicopter like a CX2 or similar 4,get some sort of training gear 5 only hover in short hops to start, close to the ground and if it goes out of control put it back down 6 dont bother trying to fly round the garden until you can hover at will
 Signature Kevin R Reply address works
Harry Strybos - 20 May 2009 05:54 GMT >> Hi All >> [quoted text clipped - 32 lines] > out of control put it back down > 6 dont bother trying to fly round the garden until you can hover at will Hi Kevin
Your tips are much appreciated. As you say, my initial suspicion is that the helicopter is not setup (trimmed) properly.
I have FMS but found it would not recognize the tx unit (ESky 4040) I have for this purpose. I then bought "Clear View" over the web and it works really well. Having said that, even the ClearView heli is very difficult for me to control.
Might have something tho do with the fact that I am over sixty and don't have the excellent hand/eye coordination of younger people.
I will try and get some help.
Harry
Kevin - 20 May 2009 08:51 GMT >>> Hi All >>> [quoted text clipped - 49 lines] > > Harry I am no spring chicken :-) but not 50 just yet, just keep playing on the sim until you can hover for long periods and the helicopter does what you want it to do, not the other way around, I spent months playing on a sim before I even brought one,I never thought I would find them a joy to fly and wondered why people ever bothered to learn to fly the dammed things as they are always crashing & you have to fly them all the time , they are still not the love of my life, planes are but I am getting better but flying them is still not second nature and hard work on the eyes and brain even after a few years ( I dont fly every week )
the Blade CX2 or MCX style machines are easier to fly than your choices but you have to relearn a bit when you step up to a CP machine as they behave so differently and are great indoors but useless in any sort of breeze,but they ideal for you in the garage, my 21 son who's a pure beginner at any sort of RC flying found my CX2 hard to fly but a club member who flies planes, found it quite easy and was quickly flying circuits round the club hall, so keep up on the sim its cheaper and a lot quicker to learn as the reset button is easier than replacing the broken bits
 Signature Kevin R Reply address works
Steve R. - 20 May 2009 03:38 GMT > Hi All > [quoted text clipped - 18 lines] > > Harry Hi Harry,
Welcome to the world of model helicopters. What you're experiencing is something that almost all of us had to deal with at some point along the way. The previous post that mentions the "chicken or the egg" conundrum is pretty close. If you can't fly well yet, you really can't properly trim the model and if the model isn't properly trimmed, you'll have little success flying it with any real precision. If you've got anyone close that can help you go over the bird and make sure it is properly trimmed, that'll go a long way for you. At least if things don't go well, you'll know it's you and not the model.
Another thing to keep in mind is that, even if the model is perfectly trimmed in the air, it will almost never be for the initial lift off. You'll have to learn to hold whatever controls you need to, to get it to come off the ground straight. Once it is airborne, you can neutralize those control inputs for a stable hover and then you should be pretty much good to go. The sim suggestion is one of the better ones. You can practice all day long and not have to worry about damaging anything, including you wallet.
Helicopters, both the models and the 100% scale versions, are very maneuverable and offer high levels of control authority. That comes at the expense of stability but once you start getting a handle on them, it's not a big deal. Get the sim and practice, practice, practice! Be sure you concentrate on the hover at first. It's too easy to let the "model" move off and then start flying around. Try not to do that. You really do need to master the hover first as the real thing won't be nearly as forgiving as the sim will be!
Good luck, Steve R.
Harry Strybos - 20 May 2009 05:38 GMT > Hi All > [quoted text clipped - 18 lines] > > Harry Thanks to all the people that replied to my question. Your advice was excellent.
I will get someone to help me.
Thank you
jabra - 20 May 2009 22:33 GMT training to fly helis isn't that simple as flying planes.but i thin you'll have faster chance to learn the control. with planes you'll star with flight sims. then probably 4 ch planes.. but, before you get t that you'll really have to spend some time with sims.
oh btw, you should practice with 3/4 ch coaxial helis..probably lik this 'wasp V2 (http://www.twift.com/RC%20Toys%20&%20Hobby/Skyartec%20WASP%20V2%20-%204%20Channe l%20RC%20Helicopter.html
don't try to master 2 chs. u'll go nowhere
-- jabr
RogerN - 21 May 2009 17:15 GMT I've been flying heli's for around 18 years and find the little electric heli's a handful to control. I have a Blade CP, Blade 400, and T-Rex 450 SE V2 and all are a handful until after I haven't flown for a while. I also have larger heli's, I have 2 heli's with 90 4-stroke engines and an X-cell Graphite with a 60 two stroke, plus other 60, 46, and 30 size glow heli's.... Anyway, the bigger they are the easier they are to fly as they give me more response time. On the down side, the bigger ones cost a lot more dollars to buy and repair. I'm not sure this is a good analogy but a small helicopter is sort of like balancing a ping pong ball (a little mistake and it's off fast) and a larger heli would be more like balancing a beach ball (same concept but you have more time to correct).
My son has a Blade CX2 and it's a nice little heli but although he can fly it, he still can't fly the other heli's of Real Flight. The Blade CX2 is a lot of fun but it's limited in how useful it will be in learning to fly your other heli's, not useless but limited.
I would recommend for you to somehow get a simulator that you can use, develop the reflexes to control the model and then go to flying the model from there. I have Real Flight V 4.5 and I find the little helis difficult to fly until I practice on the simulator for a while.
Good Luck RogerN
> Hi All > [quoted text clipped - 18 lines] > > Harry Steve R. - 22 May 2009 01:01 GMT > I've been flying heli's for around 18 years and find the little electric > heli's a handful to control. I have a Blade CP, Blade 400, and T-Rex 450 > SE V2 and all are a handful until after I haven't flown for a while. > Good Luck > RogerN While that can certainly be true, and smaller birds are naturally not as stable as the larger versions, it doesn't have to be that way. Given a proper setup, it's amazing how stable a T-Rex 450 can be. I've flown several that were better than the average 30 size bird I've played with.
Setup is everything with any model helicopter and any of them can be anywhere between drop dead stable to lightning fast on the controls.
Bruno - 23 May 2009 04:47 GMT >Given a >proper setup, it's amazing how stable a T-Rex 450 can be. I've flown >several that were better than the average 30 size bird I've played with. > >Setup is everything with any model helicopter and any of them can be >anywhere between drop dead stable to lightning fast on the controls. I agree.
I used to fly a Raptor 50 and now have a heavy gasser and a T-Rex 450SE V2.
The gasser of course has an entirely different timing on maneuvers (which I love). I set up my T-Rex to be just a bit tamer than the norm for a small electric, so it behaves more like my former Raptor.
This is one of the (many) beauties of those machines: you can tune them to be the particular beast you enjoy most.
Kevin - 23 May 2009 09:21 GMT >> Given a >> proper setup, it's amazing how stable a T-Rex 450 can be. I've flown [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > This is one of the (many) beauties of those machines: you can tune > them to be the particular beast you enjoy most. any idea how you can speed the tail up ? I have full movement but its still not as fast as I would expect or do I just need more head speed?
 Signature Kevin R Reply address works
Steve R. - 23 May 2009 14:49 GMT > any idea how you can speed the tail up ? I have full movement but its > still not as fast as I would expect or do I just need more head speed? Kevin,
What kind of gyro are you using? I can't speak for all of them out there but most heading hold gyros I've flown use the rudder ATV's or End Point Adjustments to control the pirouette speeds of the bird. The gyro will give you a specific turning rate based on how far over you're holding the control. The thing is, the gyro doesn't care if you're hold the stick half way over with ATV's set at 100% or holding the stick all the way over with the ATV's set at 50%.
Try turning up your rudder ATV's and see what happens. Let us know if it works! :-)
Good luck & Fly Safe, Steve R.
Kevin - 26 May 2009 20:40 GMT >> any idea how you can speed the tail up ? I have full movement but its >> still not as fast as I would expect or do I just need more head speed? [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > Good luck & Fly Safe, > Steve R. I am using a Futaba GY240 and a digital servo not sure what settings I have at the moment not played with it for a while but I will try and get it out later
 Signature Kevin R Reply address works
Steve R. - 26 May 2009 23:10 GMT >>> any idea how you can speed the tail up ? I have full movement but its >>> still not as fast as I would expect or do I just need more head speed? [quoted text clipped - 17 lines] > have at the moment not played with it for a while but I will try and get > it out later Hi Kevin,
I'm a long time Futaba fan. What I said should work just fine with the GY 240.
Good luck & Fly Safe, Steve R.
Harry Strybos - 24 May 2009 05:54 GMT > Hi All > [quoted text clipped - 18 lines] > > Harry Hey....I did it. I took your advice and bought a CX heli (Twister Agressor) and after a couple of hours of practice I can now hover it with some level of control. I reckon a few more hours to get it stable (not overeact) and then I will start doing forward, backward, etc. Thanks for all your help. What an enourmous buzz.....:)
Cheers, Harry
sligoNoSPAMjoe@hotmail.com - 24 May 2009 19:58 GMT
>Hey....I did it. I took your advice and bought a CX heli (Twister Agressor) >and after a couple of hours of practice I can now hover it with some level [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > >Cheers, Harry I am glad to hear you are not starting. Practice will make it easier and better.
Steve R. - 24 May 2009 21:48 GMT > "Harry Strybos" <nospam@nospam.com.au> wrote in message > > Thanks for all your help. What an enourmous buzz.....:) > > Cheers, Harry Yes it is! :-D
Congrats and Fly Safe! Steve R.
|
|
|