Thanks for those points and the site. How can I find out what the minimum
voltages can be, of the transmitter and receiver, before I hit any dangerous
threshold of having a runaway car to the next county? ;-)
--
Thanks again, Steve
> A small but important point - a failsafe will not help you if the rx pack
> completely dies of course, since the failsafe itself is powered off the
[quoted text clipped - 23 lines]
> > out there, http://www.ofna.com/failsafe-micro.html should give you an
> > idea of what they do.
Rick Russell - 28 Jul 2004 19:13 GMT
> Thanks for those points and the site. How can I find out what the minimum
> voltages can be, of the transmitter and receiver, before I hit any dangerous
> threshold of having a runaway car to the next county? ;-)
NiCd and NiMH batteries have a high initial peak voltage, a stable
voltage for most of their operation, then they drop suddenly ("dump")
to a very low voltage.
So, anything below the stable voltage means that the pack is almost
dead. Look at the discharge graphs on
http://www.hobbytalk.com/modules.php?op=modload&name=Sections&file=index&req=vie
warticle&artid=112&page=1
These are 6-cell car packs under high load.
to see what I mean. At about 1 volt per cell, you are close to total
failure.
Rick R.
mike - 29 Jul 2004 06:38 GMT
I can't answer that Q, but I can say that most failsafes will cut in when
the Rx pack drops below 4.8 volts
> Thanks for those points and the site. How can I find out what the minimum
> voltages can be, of the transmitter and receiver, before I hit any dangerous
[quoted text clipped - 39 lines]
> Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
> Version: 6.0.726 / Virus Database: 481 - Release Date: 7/22/04
> A small but important point - a failsafe will not help you if the rx pack
> completely dies of course, since the failsafe itself is powered off the
> pack. A mechanical spring (I've even seen a rubber band) is also required to
> be 100% safe.
Although technically correct I've found in practice that even when the
receiver batteries die the receiver electronics suffer before the failsafe
as the failsafe works to a lower supply voltage. This has meant that when
my batteries died the receiver gave up the ghost, the failsafe kicked in and
pulled the servo hard against the throttle tensioner spring. Because the
servo was now under high load on a flat battery pack the supply voltage
dropped and it self regulated.
If your pack dies very quickly, your fail safe doesn't work at low voltages
or you lose connection from your battery pack you will be screwed without
Mike's suggested mechanical spring but it will flatten your battery pack
much quicker!
:)