Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
General
ModelsRailroadsRockets
Radio Controlled
Air ModelsHelicoptersLand ModelsWater Models
ModelGeeks.com
Contact UsLink To UsSearch & Site Map

Model Forum / Radio Controlled / Land Models / February 2006



Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Question about transmitters...

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
ridethelightning - 04 Feb 2006 02:23 GMT
I've got a fairly large RTR that was a gift about 10 years ago called a
Supermegatron.  It is an electric buggy type, about 20" long, 4x4 with
two motors one for front and one for back and runs off a standard 7.2v
pack.   This thing has really taken a beating over the years and has
never had a problem.  I recently purchased a new charger and batteries
and dug it out of the basement for my 8year old.  Problem is it does
not have a very good range, only about 50'.  I took it apart, and the
receiver seems to be built into the internal control board which is
sealed inside the plastic chassis, and I don't think it can be
replaced.  So my question is...will I benefit from purchasing a new and
better transmitter even though I won't be able to replace the receiver
in the car (27mhz)?

I have been considering buying a whole new vehicle (electric not nitro)
but just have not been that impressed with what I've seen.  I could be
wrong, but I have this feeling that what I get will not be much if any
better than what I already have.  Any help or suggestions would be much
appreciated.  Thanks!
nospam@noway.com - 04 Feb 2006 03:50 GMT
> I've got a fairly large RTR that was a gift about 10 years ago called a
> Supermegatron.  It is an electric buggy type, about 20" long, 4x4 with
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> better than what I already have.  Any help or suggestions would be much
> appreciated.  Thanks!

1 in 4 chance it's the tx that's bad.  You could snag a 27Mhz tx on e-bay
for next to nothing so worst case you'd be out a few bucks.  It could also
be the crystals, or it could be the rx, or it could be interference on the
channel you're running on.  The only way to tell is to start replacing stuff
with known good components until you've ruled everything out.

I had an AM 75Mhz system not too long ago with the same problem, about 50'
range in all of the areas I run in, covering maybe 25 square miles around
where I live.  Took it out to the track an hour away and range was infinite.
To this day I have no idea why it acted funny in my locale and fine
everywhere else.

If it were me I'd buy something new for you and the lad.  R/C has come a
LONG way in 10 years, especially in the electric category.

Doc
kenji - 04 Feb 2006 04:30 GMT
> I have been considering buying a whole new vehicle (electric not nitro)
> but just have not been that impressed with what I've seen.

what have you "seen"?

this post sounds like a troll
ridethelightning - 04 Feb 2006 13:15 GMT
> > I have been considering buying a whole new vehicle (electric not nitro)
> > but just have not been that impressed with what I've seen.
>
> what have you "seen"?
>
> this post sounds like a troll

I've got several hobbies and am a member of several discussion groups
which I post on regularly.  This is the first time I've been accused of
being a troll...curious what about my post makes me a troll.

I am definately not an "expert" RC modeler.  Something I've been into
since I was a kid, but have never done anything more than toyed around
in the back yard.  Like I said...I got this particular car as a gift
from my wife, and the RTR package was in the area of $250.  I know that
is nothing compared to what you can spend on a decent car with
upgrades, especially if it is nitro.  I was just hoping to salvage this
thing because it still runs like a champ.  The only dual engine
electric I've seen is the E-Maxx (and some other one that comes with
numerous accesories that I already have from Hotbodies).  I'm sure the
E-Maxx is well worth the money, but then I already have a dual engine
electric that may be old but runs good - just with no range.  It was a
pretty simple question that I felt someone with more experience could
answer.  Will upgrading my transmitter without replacing the receiver
in the car help me?

Guess I will follow the first advise I got and see what I can get on
Ebay.
kenji - 04 Feb 2006 14:29 GMT
> > > I have been considering buying a whole new vehicle (electric not nitro)
> > > but just have not been that impressed with what I've seen.
[quoted text clipped - 24 lines]
> Guess I will follow the first advise I got and see what I can get on
> Ebay.

I did a 2 minute google and couldn't find the vehicle you mentioned.

any place on the internet that we can see this product?

Why only do dual motor electric vehicles catch your fancy?
ridethelightning - 04 Feb 2006 21:49 GMT
> > > > I have been considering buying a whole new vehicle (electric not nitro)
> > > > but just have not been that impressed with what I've seen.
[quoted text clipped - 30 lines]
>
> Why only do dual motor electric vehicles catch your fancy?
kenji - 04 Feb 2006 22:18 GMT
nice post!!

> > > > > I have been considering buying a whole new vehicle (electric not
> > > > > nitro)
[quoted text clipped - 31 lines]
> >
> > Why only do dual motor electric vehicles catch your fancy?
ridethelightning - 04 Feb 2006 21:57 GMT
> I did a 2 minute google and couldn't find the vehicle you mentioned.
>
> any place on the internet that we can see this product?
>
> Why only do dual motor electric vehicles catch your fancy?

Dude...why do you only answer my questions with more questions...which
are completely unrelated to my original question.  I'll answer it
(something you have yet to do with my question in your two
posts)...because you are an a.s.  You are the troll.

Of course I've already searched the internet for more info on the
vehicle.   I will not repeat myself...my fear is that I will spend a
couple of hundred on new vehicle that may not even be on par with what
I already have.   After all that I have read the last few weeks, I
think I may decide to go the route of a nitro monster truck.  Need to
think on it a little more, and do some more research on my own as far
as the transmitter goes.  You are a dickhead and have been of no help
whatsoever.   My first post on this site has not been a good
one...thanks for nothing.
kenji - 04 Feb 2006 22:17 GMT
> > I did a 2 minute google and couldn't find the vehicle you mentioned.
> >
[quoted text clipped - 16 lines]
> whatsoever.   My first post on this site has not been a good
> one...thanks for nothing.

"dude", you asked if we could help. Ideally we'd look over your shoulder
at the actual vehicle. Second best thing in this scenario is for one of
use to see schmematic or photos of the working parts of your truck.
that's why I asked.

Great. I spend a little time thinking I might be helpful and you throw
sh.t at me.

good luck with the probs on your broken toy truck
ridethelightning - 04 Feb 2006 23:09 GMT
> "dude", you asked if we could help. Ideally we'd look over your shoulder
> at the actual vehicle. Second best thing in this scenario is for one of
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
>
> good luck with the probs on your broken toy truck

Just remember...you threw first.  In a perfect world, I would have the
schematic and would not need your help would I?

OK...Here is your chance if you still want to help.  Age old question.
First nitro...Savage (I do have some tall grass and obsticles in my
yard) or Hellfire - just plain sweet and fast as hell (thus the name).
Most important is toughness and reliability, followed closely by go
anywhere durability and speed.
kenji - 04 Feb 2006 23:15 GMT
> > "dude", you asked if we could help. Ideally we'd look over your shoulder
> > at the actual vehicle. Second best thing in this scenario is for one of
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> Most important is toughness and reliability, followed closely by go
> anywhere durability and speed.

If you are going to race you could get either. Hellfire is in truggy
class at our track Savage is in monster truck class.

For pure bashing and wanting a truck that takes alot of punishment and
is real fun...Savage.  Being that the Hellfire is new there's a lot less
upgrades and less community knowledge about the truck.

Here's a 14MB .WMV file with a hellfire on a track:

http://www.robertlundquist.com/supercrossrc.htm
nospam@noway.com - 05 Feb 2006 00:31 GMT
>> I did a 2 minute google and couldn't find the vehicle you mentioned.
>>
[quoted text clipped - 16 lines]
> whatsoever.   My first post on this site has not been a good
> one...thanks for nothing.

Now now children let's play nice!  You got the answer you were looking for
as the first response to this post (by yours truly).  The answer is "maybe."
Let's not get into a pissing match about it.  I can personally guarantee you
that any electric you buy today that is hobby grade will smack the poop out
of what you have right now.

As for your other question, first let me offer some congrats on two
excellent choices.  Are you going to bash or race with said vehicle?
Hellfire will do both pretty well.  Savage needs extensive modification IMO
to be track worthy as it is a true monster truck right down to the handling
characteristics (not good w/o modification).  I bash with a MT (Savage) and
Truggy (Sportwerks Mayhem ST) and both are right at home in tall grass,
gravel, dirt, mud, you name it.  Savage can plow right over stuff I have to
drive around in my Mayhem.  There are trade offs either way.

Doc
MacPhreak - 05 Feb 2006 01:03 GMT
>>>I have been considering buying a whole new vehicle (electric not nitro)
>>>but just have not been that impressed with what I've seen.
[quoted text clipped - 24 lines]
> Guess I will follow the first advise I got and see what I can get on
> Ebay.

I am curious to see this RC of yours. Inside and out if that is
possible. If you can, just send the pictures to me and I can post them
on my site for all to see.

The advice given in SOME of the other posts about getting a transmitter
on ebay is sound but I would go for a full radio set(Used of course).
This way you can replace everything if you are so inclined. It is
possible to remove the old system completely and replace it, buuuuuuut
(and you knew that was coming) it may take some hacking to get it in
there. I have done my share of hacking GOOD radios into RC's that were
not ment to accept them but in most cases it takes a bit of imagination
 and some good tools.

If you decide to switch the radio completely there are  2 issues you
will encounter.
1) you will need to find a way to install the servo that came with the
Radio. usually you can fit it where the old one is with a bit of cutting
and getting yourself some servo mounts for it as well(if needed or you
can make them)

2) You will either need to get a Mechanical speed control unit(not
recommended) or an Electronic Speed Control unit. This is up to you but
the Mechanical one will also need to be attached to a servo.

MacPhreak
ridethelightning - 05 Feb 2006 10:05 GMT
Thanks very much to all took the time to think about my issue.  Based
on what I have heard, I doubt it is worth going to the trouble of
replacing the radio.  I know none of you have seen the insided of this
thing, but I have...and it was clearly meant to be an off the shelf
unit.  The crystals are swappable, and SOME of the mechanical parts,
but what you are proposing sounds a little over the top for the design
of the vehicle.  I still intend to keep it (at least it works for short
range play) probably just as a beater - first RC for my kid.  Maybe not
on par with the new stuff, but a heck of a lot nicer than what I had at
his age.  Probably after I get a feel for nitro, it will be retired (or
ebay'd).   I am actually on my way out - got a long work day ahead of
me, but if I find the time later this week, I'll take some pictures and
email them to ya.

And by the way Doc...everything I've read about the speed and
durability of the truggy's makes me lean in that direction.  However,
most of the use will just be back yard stuff, and I live on a mountain
(in PA)  more of just a big hill really.  But there are lots of rocks
(some pretty big) and other obstacles that I'm sure the MT would bounce
right over.  Wish the wife would let be get one of each - but not gonna
happen.  

Thanks again.
nospam@noway.com - 05 Feb 2006 19:20 GMT
> Thanks very much to all took the time to think about my issue.  Based
> on what I have heard, I doubt it is worth going to the trouble of
[quoted text clipped - 19 lines]
>
> Thanks again.

The largest "weakness" with the truggies IME for bashing is their limited
ground clearance.  You can crank up the shock pre-load to get the ride
height to that of a MT, but it throws the driveline and suspension geometry
way off (not good!).  The only way to really raise the ride height of a
truggy w/o messing up the driveline and steering geometry would be a set of
40 series tires that would allow the geometry to stay the same while raising
the truck and inch or so at the same time.  My truggy is superior to my MT
in every way (speed, durability, handling, jumping, maintenance) except
ground clearance which makes some obstacles not drive-overable.

Doc
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2009 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.