Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
General
ModelsRailroadsRockets
Radio Controlled
Air ModelsHelicoptersLand ModelsWater Models
ModelGeeks.com
Contact UsLink To UsSearch & Site Map

Model Forum / General / Models / September 2008



Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

ARM: Review - DML 1/72 Sd.Kfz. 251/1 Ausf. C with towed 3.7 cm Pak     35/36

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
AMPSOne@aol.com - 27 Sep 2008 19:00 GMT
Kit Review: Dragon Models Limited 1/72 Armor Pro Series Kit No.7371;
Sd.Kfz. 251/2 Ausf. C Rivetted Version and 3.7 cm Pak 35/36; 169
parts(152 in grey styrene, 14 etched brass, 2 DS plastic track runs, 1
length of stiff wire); price about US$14-16

Advantages: very nice, clean model of this popular vehicle in “small
scale”; unique but effective method of assembling running gear; towed
“doorknocker” nicely done

Disadvantages: RP parts (as in right puny!)

Rating: Highly Recommended

Recommendation: for all German WWII “Small Scale” fans

    After some hiatus DML has issued another variant of their popular
1/72 scale family of German medium halftracks, this time as the
infantry carrier with a towed version of the 3.7mm Pak 35/36 antitank
gun.

    Recent information continues to give a better picture of why the
Germans were so unhappy with this gun so soon in the war. Designed in
tandem with the Soviets in 1930, at that time the gun was capable of
defeating any armor being built in the world. But by the time it got
into service, heavier armor was beginning to come off the production
lines (such as the Char 2B) and when the Germans went into Russia it
was nearly useless against the new T-34 and KV tank designs. One
recent Russian article noted the frustration of a German antitank team
leader whose gunner put 20 shots into a T-34 at point blank range
(about 100 meters) but did no useful damage. He noted the only thing
that saved them was the fact that the Soviet tankers could not see him
as he was in a blind spot for the tank’s crew.

    While the Soviets changed the design of the gun to 45mm caliber so it
could fire a useful HE or canister round, the Germans were stuck with
this gun and could only use it as an auxiliary weapon after the
Soviets began to replace their pre-war and early model light tanks
with heavier ones.

    For this kit DML has combined their previous Sd.Kfz. 251 Ausf. C hull
with its applique etched brass lower hull riveting with molds based on
their “Stroke 10" commander’s variants with the 3.7 cm gun on the roof
of the fighting compartment with a brand new carriage for the gun.
Therefore the kit is as previous models.

    The new upper hull, like the previous Cs and Ds, is not a pantograph
of the larger kits but is based on the same research and drawings. The
lower hull is a single piece pan, less the rear area, and the axles
are molded on the lower hull. The running gear for each side consists
of a rear (inside) wheel section, a center wheel section, three outer
road wheels, and drivers. Once installed the connectors between the
individual wheels on the inside and the center are not visible, so it
helps speed up assembly while making it easier to get things aligned.
Tracks are the gluable DS plastic, so you can also get them to settle
down on top of the road wheels with some care.

    Unlike the last Ausf. C kit (7306) this kit no longer comes with the
option of either the C (welded) or C (rivetted) upper hulls. Therefore
the modeler must use six sections of etched brass for the lower hull
applique to provide scale rivets. As before openings have been left to
mount the fenders through the brass to the hull.

    Interior bits include the various control levers, rifles, MP
submachine guns, and other items. The hinge mechanisms for the doors
are single pieces, but are non-operating types. They cement to the
lower rear section, as the upper hull has the rear angular parts of
the hull attached to it. The four front viewers are separate parts and
can be cemented either open or closed as well, as is the hood assembly
with two flaps. No engine or interior is provided for the engine bay.

    The fenders are one-piece units with the stowage bins still closed
parts. RP parts include the “Notek” headlight and mount and the drum
magazines for the two MG 34 machine guns. The weapons appear to be
very close to scale, something I don’t recall from other manufacturers
in the past!

        The Pak 35/36 gun is very neatly done with a “slide molded” open
bore so it is up to speed with the larger kits. The gun comes on a
small sprue of two parts and a full carriage of 17 parts comes on
another. The modeler has a choice of towed or deployed configurations,
and the gun is very petite and nicely done. No brass gun shield option
is provided of the gun.

    Directions are standard DML fare, but due to the fewer parts in their
1/72 series kits they are not as busy and much easier to read.

    Painting and marking options are provided for one unit, our old
friend “Unidentified unit”, Eastern Front 1942, with hasty mud stripe
camouflage over grey.) Two generic Cartograf sheets (crosses and
license plates) are provided.

    Overall another nice effort, and for early war modeling or dioramas
this will be a nice choice.

    Thanks to Freddie Leung of DML for the review sample.

Cookie Sewell
Mike Smith - 28 Sep 2008 00:09 GMT
Kit Review: Dragon Models Limited 1/72 Armor Pro Series Kit No.7371;
Sd.Kfz. 251/2 Ausf. C Rivetted Version and 3.7 cm Pak 35/36; 169
parts(152 in grey styrene, 14 etched brass, 2 DS plastic track runs, 1
length of stiff wire); price about US$14-16

Advantages: very nice, clean model of this popular vehicle in “small
scale”; unique but effective method of assembling running gear; towed
“doorknocker” nicely done

Disadvantages: RP parts (as in right puny!)

Rating: Highly Recommended

Recommendation: for all German WWII “Small Scale” fans

After some hiatus DML has issued another variant of their popular
1/72 scale family of German medium halftracks, this time as the
infantry carrier with a towed version of the 3.7mm Pak 35/36 antitank
gun.

Recent information continues to give a better picture of why the
Germans were so unhappy with this gun so soon in the war. Designed in
tandem with the Soviets in 1930, at that time the gun was capable of
defeating any armor being built in the world. But by the time it got
into service, heavier armor was beginning to come off the production
lines (such as the Char 2B) and when the Germans went into Russia it
was nearly useless against the new T-34 and KV tank designs. One
recent Russian article noted the frustration of a German antitank team
leader whose gunner put 20 shots into a T-34 at point blank range
(about 100 meters) but did no useful damage. He noted the only thing
that saved them was the fact that the Soviet tankers could not see him
as he was in a blind spot for the tank’s crew.

While the Soviets changed the design of the gun to 45mm caliber so it
could fire a useful HE or canister round, the Germans were stuck with
this gun and could only use it as an auxiliary weapon after the
Soviets began to replace their pre-war and early model light tanks
with heavier ones.

For this kit DML has combined their previous Sd.Kfz. 251 Ausf. C hull
with its applique etched brass lower hull riveting with molds based on
their “Stroke 10" commander’s variants with the 3.7 cm gun on the roof
of the fighting compartment with a brand new carriage for the gun.
Therefore the kit is as previous models.

The new upper hull, like the previous Cs and Ds, is not a pantograph
of the larger kits but is based on the same research and drawings. The
lower hull is a single piece pan, less the rear area, and the axles
are molded on the lower hull. The running gear for each side consists
of a rear (inside) wheel section, a center wheel section, three outer
road wheels, and drivers. Once installed the connectors between the
individual wheels on the inside and the center are not visible, so it
helps speed up assembly while making it easier to get things aligned.
Tracks are the gluable DS plastic, so you can also get them to settle
down on top of the road wheels with some care.

Unlike the last Ausf. C kit (7306) this kit no longer comes with the
option of either the C (welded) or C (rivetted) upper hulls. Therefore
the modeler must use six sections of etched brass for the lower hull
applique to provide scale rivets. As before openings have been left to
mount the fenders through the brass to the hull.

Interior bits include the various control levers, rifles, MP
submachine guns, and other items. The hinge mechanisms for the doors
are single pieces, but are non-operating types. They cement to the
lower rear section, as the upper hull has the rear angular parts of
the hull attached to it. The four front viewers are separate parts and
can be cemented either open or closed as well, as is the hood assembly
with two flaps. No engine or interior is provided for the engine bay.

The fenders are one-piece units with the stowage bins still closed
parts. RP parts include the “Notek” headlight and mount and the drum
magazines for the two MG 34 machine guns. The weapons appear to be
very close to scale, something I don’t recall from other manufacturers
in the past!

The Pak 35/36 gun is very neatly done with a “slide molded” open
bore so it is up to speed with the larger kits. The gun comes on a
small sprue of two parts and a full carriage of 17 parts comes on
another. The modeler has a choice of towed or deployed configurations,
and the gun is very petite and nicely done. No brass gun shield option
is provided of the gun.

Directions are standard DML fare, but due to the fewer parts in their
1/72 series kits they are not as busy and much easier to read.

Painting and marking options are provided for one unit, our old
friend “Unidentified unit”, Eastern Front 1942, with hasty mud stripe
camouflage over grey.) Two generic Cartograf sheets (crosses and
license plates) are provided.

Overall another nice effort, and for early war modeling or dioramas
this will be a nice choice.

Thanks to Freddie Leung of DML for the review sample.

Cookie Sewell

Interesting - Thanks for that.

Re the gun - The Germans developed a hollow charge round that fitted over
the outside of the muzzle, this was fired using a blank. IIRC this was
effective against a T34 but not much use against the KV (which is why the
Germans started using the 88mm AA guns in the AT role in the first place,
although these did have a telescopic sight wheras the British 3.7 inch did
not (designed for electronic control)).

Regards

Mike
AMPSOne@aol.com - 28 Sep 2008 19:30 GMT
Mike,

That is true, but the Stielgranate 41  was in low supply, awkward to
suse except once from ambush, and not very stable in flight. From
Soviet sources it was no encountered very much at all and they make no
special mention of it in their histories.

88m guns have nothing to do with the 37mm ones, so not sure why you
mentioned this. Most German records also indicate that up until 1943
the use of the 8.8 cm Flak guns as antitank weapons was a last-ditch
move; while the gun was certainly effective, it involved setting it up
in fixed positions in order to provide it a wide arc of fire (that
from the carriage was very narrow due to recoil), using Luftwaffe
troops as Wehrmacht assets, and risking very expensive and limited AA
assets for a situation which made them highly vulnerable to artillery
fire.

Cookie Sewell
someone@some.domain - 28 Sep 2008 20:47 GMT
>Mike,
>
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
>
>Cookie Sewell
gee, talk to any europeon command foot soldier and he'll tell you they had
thousands of them. they were on every road, in every field and shot down
aircraft with one shot and tanks with the next. all the crews were evil ss
bastards who drank blood and ate french children. the only way to kill them
was by having 100 shermans sneak up on them one at a time and blast away for
hours until you got one.
one gun had gone from africa to russia to normandy and had so many white rings
on the barrel thay had to paint them 1mm thick. all the crew had iron cross's
with oak leaves, diamonds and ruby roses, special for them.
when i was a kid in germany, we heard so much talk from vets of both sides,
the first time we saw an 88, we were shocked and sure there was a mistake.
the german soldiers believed the myths as much as the amis!
Mike Smith - 29 Sep 2008 00:02 GMT
> In article
> <b559e447-76dd-40cb-ae45-563b1ae98a81@m73g2000hsh.googlegroups.com>,
[quoted text clipped - 33 lines]
> the first time we saw an 88, we were shocked and sure there was a mistake.
> the german soldiers believed the myths as much as the amis!

The T34 85 leveled the playing field a bit, they could engage 88s at similar
ranges.
Oddly though the 'doorknocker' seems to have stayed in service a lot longer
than it should have, anyone know how it fared against the Sherman (seeing as
that was the most numerous allied tank in the west)?

Mike
Bruce Probst - 30 Sep 2008 06:17 GMT
> Oddly though the 'doorknocker' seems to have stayed in service a lot longer
> than it should have, anyone know how it fared against the Sherman (seeing as
> that was the most numerous allied tank in the west)?

There would have been very few encounters between Shermans and the Pak
35/36, I would think.  By the time the Shermans were appearing on the
battlefields in any numbers the standard German AT guns were the PaK
38 (50mm) and the PaK 40 (75mm), either of which were more than
capable of ruining a Sherman's day.  I don't know for certain, but I
suspect that the majority of in-service 37mm after 1942 were either
mounted on half-tracks (or similar) or relegated to "quiet" areas like
Norway, or given (or sold) to Germany's allies like Hungary and
Romania.

I doubt that the 37mm round would have been very much more effective
against a Sherman than it was vs. a T-34.  Remember, the Germans had
trouble with the French and British armour in 1940!  Sherman armour
was not amazing compared to many of its contemporaries, but it was
plenty good enough to protect against obsolescent equipment like the
PaK 35/36.

Bruce
Melbourne, Australia
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2009 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.