Well Rob. You're entitled to your opinion, but I have it on good
authority that you're wrong, and you've provided no evidence that
these trains have devalued.
The Reeses car set just sold for $90. No ware near worthless, and this
set is already at $102. I mean, if you don't want them, don't buy
them. I certainly am not interested these product endorcement trains,
which is why I'm selling them rather than setting them up.
But, I have to wonder why you're so interested in putting down my
auctions. It seems rude and little unfair.
If this is the wrong place to advertise trains for sale I'm sorry.
This is the only newsgroup I have access to that specifically deals
with model railroading.
If my price is out of line with some "Blue Book" value, please give me
a verifiable referance. That would actually help me.
But trolling my auction posts because you don't like them, or me,
well... it's a little childish if you ask me.
I have to wonder what you expect to get out devalueing my auction?
> Well Rob. You're entitled to your opinion, but I have it on good
> authority that you're wrong, and you've provided no evidence that
> these trains have devalued.
>"The only quote I've seen on pricing them is $250 for the set. I'm
>starting the bidding at $80 with a Buy It Now of $225."
Well, I did say I was sorry, I guess I meant sorry, you did not get the
$250.00 you thought it was worth/saw it sell for, or the $225.00 +
shipping you thought it was worth, only $90.00 + shipping, or $22.50
each for ore cars with sprung metal trucks that sell for $12.95/pr. I
guess they have gone down in value.
The cars in the Hershey set aren't nearly as nice as the ore cars. It's
just an entry level starter set, and not very prototypical, even in the
3-rail world. You will probably get a fair price for the set, but not a
collector value. The running gear for the loco, with the shell for
repaint, is alone worth about $45-$55.
The "odd cars from the set" you saw may have been add-ons, with Hershey
branding. The K-Line catalogs have been chock full of them for years.
There is just too much K-Line out there and too few people hunting it
down... there are a few K-Line collectibles, though, out of VERY limited
production runs. Even the club & convention cars, though, unless
prototypical, fetch less than new(Lionel too, often). I run all my
K-Line & MTH stuff.
Of course, eBay can always be called upon to produce anomalies, in both
directions. Sellers should always seek a 30:1 sell:buy ratio, though.
With regard to posting ads here, I'm no expert, but usenet has
designated groups for posting FA & FS items, my understanding is that
this is not one of them, but I've never called anyone on it, and I'm not
now. It really isn't that big of a problem here like it is in other
groups. Good luck on your auctions. I see you are very busy selling
stuff of all kinds.
Rob
Phueque - 31 Dec 2004 07:42 GMT
Well thanks for responding. Sorry if I came back too hard.
If some one does want to call me on posting ads here I will stop.
I'm not really into model RR. I'm only selling these trains that I've
basically inherited. I have boxes and boxes of stuff to go through and
NO real idea where to move it. Some of it I will keep because *I*
think it's cool. Some I expect won't move because dad re-boxed a lot
of stuff to fit int the closet.
All I can do is search what resources are available to me and guess at
the rest.
Here is one of my sources for the value of this set.
http://members.aol.com/irenescol/Page5.html
I had a couple of others at one time that were in the same $250 Ball
park, but the links have gone dead or the Hershey trains have been
removed from them. Probably cause ther were sold.
As with any auction you list a "buy it now" for what it's highest
worth and a reserve for what you're willing to accept. I figured $90
was ok for 4 cars. Hell the economy is so bad I'm lucky if any one can
afford to buy anything.
For these last two auctions I used a drop off service to package them
and list the adds. So *I* am not selling everything listed under that
name. Just the trains Ilisted.
I'm more of a comic book and action figure collector, so to my mind,
when I can't find something for sale anywhere else, that makes is rare
and more valuable.
>With regard to posting ads here, I'm no expert, but usenet has
>designated groups for posting FA & FS items, my understanding is that
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
>
>Rob