Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
General
ModelsRailroadsRockets
Radio Controlled
Air ModelsHelicoptersLand ModelsWater Models
ModelGeeks.com
Contact UsLink To UsSearch & Site Map

Model Forum / General / Railroads / April 2006



Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Appropriate rolling stock for era ?

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Stein R - 28 Apr 2006 05:20 GMT
Hi --

I am working on modelling two small H0 scale layouts based on the
Minnesota Transfer Railway (MTRY) ca 1963.

One of the layouts is an interchange yard, where cars are dropped off by
several other railroad lines, including the Northern Pacific, the Great
Northern, the Chicago & North Western, and a few others - the Milwaukee
Road, the Soo line, the other layout is local switching to pick up and
drop off freight cars to local industries.

I have aquired a few engines which should be reasonably right for the
era I model :
- One Alco S1 (to be repainted for the MTRY)
- One RS-3 in Great Northern colors
- One EMD GP30 in Great Northern colors
- One EMD GP7 in Northern Pacific colors
- One Fairbanks Morse H-16-44 Baby Trainmaster (to repaint for C&NW)

But I was wondering about the freight cars and cabooses I have gathered,

Which of these can be used as is ? Which needs a repaint job to be
reasonably credible for a Twin Cities location in 1963 ? And which car
types (if any) simply were not available in 1963 ?

Boxcars:
40’ Great Northern Box Car (Dark Green)
40' Milwaukee Road Box Car (Yellow)
40' Union Pacific Box Car (Red)
40' Union Pacific Box Car (Armor Yellow)
40' Union Pacific Box Car (Armor Yellow)
40' Box Car (Pale White)
40' Box Car (Black)
40' NRT Box Car (Orange)
40' Morell Box Car (Orange)
40' Burlington Box Car (Red) - Post 1963 ???
40' Box Car (Orange)
40' Wines Box Car (Grey)
40' Dairymens Box Car (White w/Blue text)
40' Box Car (Blue and White)
50' Delson Lumber Co. Box Car (Brown)
50' R F & P Box car (dark blue)
50' Netherlands Overseas Mills Box Car (Blue & Yellow)
50' Chessie System Box Car (Orange) - post 1963 ?
50' Chessie System Box Car (Orange) - post 1963 ?
50' Burlington Box Car (Green) - post 1963 ?
50' "W" Box Car (Orange)
50' Frisco Box Car (Orange)

Tank Cars
40' single dome Tootsie Roll Tank Car (Black)
40' single dome Quaker State Oil Tank Car (White & Green)
40' single dome Hooker Chemicals (Orange)
40' single dome Cities Service (Green)
40' single dome Dupont (Green & Yellow)
40' single dome Hooker (Red)
40' single dome Texaco (Silver)
40' single dome Shell (Orange)
40' single dome Wesson (Blue, White and Green)
40' single dome Kopper Chemicals (Red)
40' single dome Kopper Chemicals (Red)
40' single dome Allied Chemicals (White)
40' single dome Allied Chemicals (White)

Open Hopper Cars
3 Bay CP Rail 70 ton Coal Hopper (Black)
3 Bay DRGW 70 ton Coal Hopper (Black)
3 Bay The Rock Hopper (Light blue)
3 Bay Hopper Car (Orange)  
3 Bay Peabody Short Line (Yellow)  
3 Bay B & M Open Hopper Car (Dark Blue)
4 Bay Cotton Belt (Dark Red)  
4 Bay Burlington (Red)  
4 Bay Cheasapeake and Ohio Open Hopper (Dark Green)
4 Bay Reading Open Hopper (Black)

Covered Hopper Cars
2 Bay Jack Frost Covered Hopper (Blue and White)  
2 Bay Haliburton Covered Hopper (Red and White)  
2 Bay B & M Covered Hopper (Dark blue)
3 Bay Naugatuck Plastics Covered Hopper (White)
3 Bay Wabash Grain Hopper (Black)
3 Bay Burlington Grain Hopper #1 (White)
3 Bay Burlington Grain Hopper #2 (White)  
3 Bay Burlington Grain Hopper #3 (White)
3 Bay Burlington Grain Hopper #4 (White)
3 Bay Burlington Grain Hopper #5 (White)
3 Bay Burlington Grain Hopper #6 (White)
3 Bay Warps Plastics Covered Hopper (Yellow)
4 Bay Sanka Covered Hopper (Red)
4 Bay "Old Dutch Cleanser" Hopper (Yellow)
4 Bay GT Grain Hopper (Blue)
4 Bay Illinois Central Grain Hopper (Orange

Gondolas and Flatcars
50' Union Pacific Gondola w/ pipe load (Armor Yellow)
40' Flatcar (Black)
40' AT&SF Flatcar (Black)
50' Great Northern Flatcar w/load (Green)
50' APL flatvar (yellow) w/2 20' Containers (white)

Smile,
Stein
Wolf Kirchmeir - 28 Apr 2006 14:49 GMT
[...]
> But I was wondering about the freight cars and cabooses I have gathered,

Rather than comment on each car, I'll give you a few rules for figuring
out what you need to know. Also look at the May Model Railroader, it has
a pretty good introductory article on boxcars.

Look for the NEW or BLT date (usually just to the right of the weight
data, sometimes to the far right next to the dimensional data.) Any date
before 1964 and after the mid-40s would be OK for your layout theme.
Pre-war cars in original condition were outlawed for interchange by
about 1960. Many were rebuilt, some were assigned to company service.

BLT refers to the construction date. NEW refers to the rebuild or
upgrade date (sometimes just a new paint job.)

The weight data should show CAPY.,  LD. LMT., and LT. WT. If there are
only two weight numbers on the car, it's too new.

Another clue is the construction: by the early 60s, wood outside braced
boxcars were rare outside of grain branches. Wood refrigerator cars
however were still quite common. The occasional composite gondola or
hopper also showed up. But about 90% of the cars were steel.

Apart from suitable era, there is also the issue of suitable loads,
hence the kinds of cars you would see. For example, plastic pellet cars
(covered hoppers, often in colourful liveries) would be plentiful around
a plastic manufacturer or petrochemical plant, but not at a team track
or freight house. IOW, some of the cars on your list are OK for era, but
perhaps not for your location.

If you want the right look for the early 60s, note that most cars were
still in "railroad drab" - oxide browns and dull reds, black, and grey
were the most common colours. However, many roads had applied large
billboard type logos to their cars by then. Great Northern stood out
with its experiments with bright red, glacier green, and orange/olive
green cars. In the 50s, many roads developed special, quite colourful
liveries for specialised services running fixed routes at fixed times.
But by the early 60s, many of these cars were relegated to the general
freight pool, and might show up anywhere.

As you can see, the history of freight construction and utilisation is
quite complex. Investigating rolling stock history can become a hobby in
itself, so beware. :-)

[...]
Stein R - 28 Apr 2006 16:08 GMT
Wolf Kirchmeir <wolfekir@sympatico.ca> wrote in news:t0p4g.4316
$fx.381855@news20.bellglobal.com:

> [...]
>> But I was wondering about the freight cars and cabooses I
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> figuring out what you need to know. Also look at the May Model
> Railroader, it has a pretty good introductory article on boxcars.

Excellent advice! On the advice of a friend over here, I have
also picked up a copy of "The Model Railroader's Guide to Indu-
stries Along the Track" by Jeff Wilson, which seems to be a very
good introductory book on the subject of industries along the
tracks and freight cars.

> Look for the NEW or BLT date (usually just to the right of the
> weight data, sometimes to the far right next to the dimensional
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> The weight data should show CAPY.,  LD. LMT., and LT. WT. If there are
> only two weight numbers on the car, it's too new.

*Very* useful advice. Thank you!

> Another clue is the construction: by the early 60s, wood outside
> braced boxcars were rare outside of grain branches. Wood refrigerator
> cars however were still quite common. The occasional composite
> gondola or hopper also showed up. But about 90% of the cars were
> steel.

Aha.


> Apart from suitable era, there is also the issue of suitable loads,
> hence the kinds of cars you would see. For example, plastic pellet
> cars (covered hoppers, often in colourful liveries) would be
> plentiful around a plastic manufacturer or petrochemical plant,
> but not at a team track or freight house. IOW, some of the cars
> on your list are OK for era, but perhaps not for your location.

Yep, that is what I figured as well. I fully expect to have to repaint
(or even retire) some of the cars I have bought, but I have bought cars
in lotsk, so I would have enough cars of a reasonable type for mostly
realistic traffic in the area and era I am modelling.

The local industries I am planning is a oil tank farm, two grain mills,
and three industries that basically can be anything that takes boxcars
and maybe the odd tank car or hopper once in a while (have bought three
Walthers kits: Heritage Furniture plant, River City Textiles and Arrow-
head Ale Brewery - we'll see what I turn them into - depends on what I
can dig up in the archieves of the Minnesota Historical Society during
my summer vacation).

See any cars on my original list that are obvious no-no's ? The list of
cars can also be found at:

http://home.online.no/~steinjr/trains/modelling/mtrr/stock.html


> If you want the right look for the early 60s, note that most cars were
> still in "railroad drab" - oxide browns and dull reds, black, and grey
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> quite complex. Investigating rolling stock history can become a hobby
> in itself, so beware. :-)

I have been properly warned, but still am too stupid too start running
away, so I guess I deserve whatever I get myself into here ... :-)

I have made careful note of your advice. Thank you !

Smile,
Stein

 
Newyorkcentralfan@bigfoot.com - 29 Apr 2006 06:55 GMT
You can try here. The Baby Boomer Freight Cars list.

http://finance.groups.yahoo.com/group/bbfcl/

Eric
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.