Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
General
ModelsRailroadsRockets
Radio Controlled
Air ModelsHelicoptersLand ModelsWater Models
ModelGeeks.com
Contact UsLink To UsSearch & Site Map

Model Forum / General / Rockets / February 2004



Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

recovery wadding

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Callum - 25 Feb 2004 15:34 GMT
I am fairly new to rocketry and have been using packets of recovery
wadding from estes. This is quite expensive where i live and i was
wondering if there are any alternatives to the shop bought packets.
Please help
Callum
Jerry Irvine - 25 Feb 2004 15:54 GMT
> I am fairly new to rocketry and have been using packets of recovery
> wadding from estes. This is quite expensive where i live and i was
> wondering if there are any alternatives to the shop bought packets.
> Please help
> Callum

1. "Dog barf" which is insulation that resembles shredded newspaper.
Lifetime supply is the minimum buy.

2. Ejection baffle, which is a plate with several small holes which acts
as a flame screen and allows the wadding to bunch up against it so you
can simply use less. Make sure it is far enough forward for your longest
motor (ever).

3. Pistons. Good idea, bad practice. Minimize their use (just like
phenolic airframes). Sorry PML (a truly great company)!

Jerry

Signature

Jerry Irvine, Box 1242, Claremont, California 91711 USA
Opinion, the whole thing. <mail to:01rocket@gte.net>
Please bring common sense back to rocketry administration.
Produce then publish.  http://www.usrockets.com
My articles valuable? Donate http://tinyurl.com/2hmgv

Fred Shecter - 25 Feb 2004 16:38 GMT
Clarification: "Dog barf" looks more like dryer lint than shredded newspaper and it is
chemically treated to not burn. It is made from extremely shredded (practically to dust)
waste paper and cardboard with the chemical treatment added. one brand sold at some home
improvement/ hardware supply stores is Cocoon brand cellulose insulation. Also known
generically as "blow-in cellulose insulation". Some Lowe's store locations carry it.

-Fred Shecter NAR 20117
http://cgi6.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewSellersOtherItems&userid=shreadvector

--
"""Remove "zorch" from address (2 places) to reply.

> > I am fairly new to rocketry and have been using packets of recovery
> > wadding from estes. This is quite expensive where i live and i was
[quoted text clipped - 21 lines]
> Produce then publish.  http://www.usrockets.com
> My articles valuable? Donate http://tinyurl.com/2hmgv
hiltyt@weinerboy.org - 25 Feb 2004 18:12 GMT
>Clarification: "Dog barf" looks more like dryer lint than shredded newspaper and it is
>chemically treated to not burn. It is made from extremely shredded (practically to dust)
>waste paper and cardboard with the chemical treatment added. one brand sold at some home
>improvement/ hardware supply stores is Cocoon brand cellulose insulation. Also known
>generically as "blow-in cellulose insulation". Some Lowe's store locations carry it.

I could never understand the use of the term "Dog Barf" to describe
the stuff anyway...

Most samples of actual "Dog Barf" I've seen usually are watery,
multi-colored, containing large chunks of partially digested food,
bones, sticks, rocks, plastic bags, and the occasional tapeworm...

<g>

tah

--

Tod A. Hilty
Hilty Information Systems

Do not look in the direction of the flash...
Curl up in a ball as you hit the ground...

Please replace weinerboy dot org with adelphia dot net for reply.
David Weinshenker - 25 Feb 2004 18:22 GMT
> >Clarification: "Dog barf" looks more like dryer lint than shredded newspaper and it is
> >chemically treated to not burn. It is made from extremely shredded (practically to dust)
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> I could never understand the use of the term "Dog Barf" to describe
> the stuff anyway...

I think the term refers to the appearance
of the material after it falls on the
ground and soaks up water.

-dave w
Fred Shecter - 25 Feb 2004 18:33 GMT
Yes. this is a bit more like Cat Barf.

;-)

--
"""Remove "zorch" from address (2 places) to reply.

> >Clarification: "Dog barf" looks more like dryer lint than shredded newspaper and it is
> >chemically treated to not burn. It is made from extremely shredded (practically to dust)
[quoted text clipped - 22 lines]
>
> Please replace weinerboy dot org with adelphia dot net for reply.
Dave Grayvis - 25 Feb 2004 19:00 GMT
> Yes. this is a bit more like Cat Barf.
>
> ;-)

Mouse chunks?
Fred Shecter - 26 Feb 2004 03:50 GMT
What, no weasel barf?????

Signature

-Fred Shecter
Auctions:
http://cgi6.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewSellersOtherItems&include=0&userid=shr
eadvector


To reply by e-mail, remove zorch two places.

> > Yes. this is a bit more like Cat Barf.
> >
> > ;-)
>
> Mouse chunks?
Dave Grayvis - 26 Feb 2004 05:54 GMT
> What, no weasel barf?????

What, is jerry sick?
Christopher Deem - 26 Feb 2004 20:54 GMT
You know, I knew someone was going to say that.

Signature

Christopher Brian Deem       NAR 12308 TRA 2256 Level II

>
> > What, no weasel barf?????
>
> What, is jerry sick?
J-o-h-n - 26 Feb 2004 04:14 GMT
WHAT?  No UNDERWEAR???

:)

> >Clarification: "Dog barf" looks more like dryer lint than shredded newspaper and it is
> >chemically treated to not burn. It is made from extremely shredded (practically to dust)
[quoted text clipped - 22 lines]
>
> Please replace weinerboy dot org with adelphia dot net for reply.
Mike Burch - 28 Feb 2004 03:49 GMT
> I could never understand the use of the term "Dog Barf" to describe
> the stuff anyway...
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
> Tod A. Hilty
> Hilty Information Systems

It's not located in home improvement stores either.  Its usually found
here on our carpet and its almost free. :-)
Jerry Irvine - 25 Feb 2004 18:39 GMT
> Clarification: "Dog barf" looks more like dryer lint than shredded newspaper
> and it is
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> generically as "blow-in cellulose insulation". Some Lowe's store locations
> carry it.

Thanks for the clarification. This should be in the FAQ. I should use it
to pack mail orders :)

> -Fred Shecter NAR 20117
> http://cgi6.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewSellersOtherItems&userid=shreadvecto
[quoted text clipped - 21 lines]
> >
> > Jerry

Signature

Jerry Irvine, Box 1242, Claremont, California 91711 USA
Opinion, the whole thing. <mail to:01rocket@gte.net>
Please bring common sense back to rocketry administration.
Produce then publish.  http://www.usrockets.com
My articles valuable? Donate http://tinyurl.com/2hmgv

Bob Kaplow - 25 Feb 2004 22:18 GMT
>> I am fairly new to rocketry and have been using packets of recovery
>> wadding from estes. This is quite expensive where i live and i was
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> 3. Pistons. Good idea, bad practice. Minimize their use (just like
> phenolic airframes). Sorry PML (a truly great company)!

I'm certainly a fan of baffles, but wnat to add a couple more choices:

4) Crepe paper. Back in the old days Centuri actually sold this as their
wadding. THe 2" strips torn up into 6" pieces work fine in questes sized
kits. For larger stuff I get the 20" wide sheets, hack it with a paper
cutter, and use it in a similar manner.

5) Don't know what it's called, but the tissue paper used for parade floats
is also flameproof. As a matter of fact, this is what Quest sells for their
wadding. Any one know where to get this in large quantities?

6) Fiberglass insulation. Many sites don't allow it, as it's not
biodegradible, but IMHO it works much better than dog barf, and usually
stays in the rocket, forming a sort of baffle that will last several
flights. It too is flameproof by law. I used to peel a layer off the
batting, roll it into a cylinder that fit the body tube, and slide it in.
Remove and reinstall between flights to get the trapped crud out.

Something to remember about wadding and baffles in general. The hot gasses
do NOT cause the damage. The burning particles do. Baffles work by passing
the gas, but blocking the hot particles that travel in a straight line. One
reason I don't really like dog barf is that  the ejection can blow a
"tunnel" through the material, allowing some particles to get to the chute
:-(

    Bob Kaplow    NAR # 18L    TRA # "Impeach the TRA BoD"
        >>> To reply, remove the TRABoD! <<<
Kaplow Klips & Baffle:    http://nira-rocketry.org/LeadingEdge/Phantom4000.pdf
   www.encompasserve.org/~kaplow_r/    www.nira-rocketry.org    www.nar.org

Save Model Rocketry from the HSA!   http://www.space-rockets.com/congress.html
Reece Talley - 25 Feb 2004 22:22 GMT
I have a huge supply of dog barf that I got for about $5.00 at a hardware
store. Bob has a point, it is possible to blow a hole through it if the
column is too short. Just what is too short?  I feel the column has to be at
least 2 BT dia in length. Thus barf is good for rockets up to 2--3 inches in
diam. After that the column gets stupidly long and weight becomes a factor.

Signature

R. J. Talley
Teacher/James Madison Fellow
NAR #69594
NRA #133073736

> >
> >> I am fairly new to rocketry and have been using packets of recovery
[quoted text clipped - 45 lines]
>
>  Save Model Rocketry from the HSA!   http://www.space-rockets.com/congress.html
hiltyt@weinerboy.org - 25 Feb 2004 22:34 GMT
>I have a huge supply of dog barf that I got for about $5.00 at a hardware
>store. Bob has a point, it is possible to blow a hole through it if the
>column is too short. Just what is too short?  I feel the column has to be at
>least 2 BT dia in length. Thus barf is good for rockets up to 2--3 inches in
>diam. After that the column gets stupidly long and weight becomes a factor.

*This* is where I've found that Estes, et.al. "wadding sheets" become
pretty handy.  Place *one* in the BT first, as flat as you can make
it, and then backfill with a decent amount of dog barf.  You won't
need nearly as much as you would if you didn't put the wadding in
first, and I've found that it acts very much like a piston at
ejection.

tah

--

Tod A. Hilty
Hilty Information Systems

Do not look in the direction of the flash...
Curl up in a ball as you hit the ground...

Please replace weinerboy dot org with adelphia dot net for reply.
Bob Kaplow - 25 Feb 2004 22:58 GMT
>>I have a huge supply of dog barf that I got for about $5.00 at a hardware
>>store. Bob has a point, it is possible to blow a hole through it if the
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> first, and I've found that it acts very much like a piston at
> ejection.

I use the large crepe sheets cut as I described earlier for doing that in
big rockets.

    Bob Kaplow    NAR # 18L    TRA # "Impeach the TRA BoD"
        >>> To reply, remove the TRABoD! <<<
Kaplow Klips & Baffle:    http://nira-rocketry.org/LeadingEdge/Phantom4000.pdf
   www.encompasserve.org/~kaplow_r/    www.nira-rocketry.org    www.nar.org

Save Model Rocketry from the HSA!   http://www.space-rockets.com/congress.html
Doug Sams - 25 Feb 2004 23:07 GMT
weinerboy wrote:
> > *This* is where I've found that Estes, et.al. "wadding sheets" become
> > pretty handy.  Place *one* in the BT first, as flat as you can make
> > it, and then backfill with a decent amount of dog barf.  You won't
> > need nearly as much as you would if you didn't put the wadding in
> > first, and I've found that it acts very much like a piston at
> > ejection.

> I use the large crepe sheets cut as I described earlier for doing that in
> big rockets.

Wow, I pretty much do like both of you.  Great minds think alike :)

Doug
hiltyt@weinerboy.org - 26 Feb 2004 00:32 GMT
>weinerboy wrote:
>> > *This* is where I've found that Estes, et.al. "wadding sheets" become
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
>
>Wow, I pretty much do like both of you.  Great minds think alike :)

Good.  I was worried that you were going to say "Simple things for
simple minds"...

<vbg>

tah

--

Tod A. Hilty
Hilty Information Systems

Do not look in the direction of the flash...
Curl up in a ball as you hit the ground...

Please replace weinerboy dot org with adelphia dot net for reply.
Jerry Irvine - 26 Feb 2004 00:44 GMT
In article
<8194ae359c38a63465b32021633292e0.39695@mygate.mailgate.org>,

> Wow, I pretty much do like both of you.  Great minds think alike :)

I wouldn't say that . . . the great minds part . . .  :)

Just wacky

Signature

Jerry Irvine, Box 1242, Claremont, California 91711 USA
Opinion, the whole thing. <mail to:01rocket@gte.net>
Please bring common sense back to rocketry administration.
Produce then publish.  http://www.usrockets.com
My articles valuable? Donate http://tinyurl.com/2hmgv

Reece Talley - 26 Feb 2004 01:19 GMT
That's exactly what I do.

Signature

R. J. Talley
Teacher/James Madison Fellow
NAR #69594
NRA #133073736

>
> >I have a huge supply of dog barf that I got for about $5.00 at a hardware
[quoted text clipped - 21 lines]
>
> Please replace weinerboy dot org with adelphia dot net for reply.
Doug Sams - 25 Feb 2004 16:44 GMT
> I am fairly new to rocketry and have been using packets of recovery
> wadding from estes. This is quite expensive where i live and i was
> wondering if there are any alternatives to the shop bought packets.
> Please help

Hi, Callum,

While I agree the thought of paying four bucks for a half roll of
toilet paper treated with Borax seems outrageous, a bag usually
lasts me a couple months or more, and I like the product.

Alternatives include cellulose wadding  (aka dog barf, shredded
newspapers treated with ~Borax and used as blown in insulation
in attics) and party paper/crepe paper/tissue paper.

Since the dog barf is not in sheet form, the ejection charge can
blow through it - ie, displace it - and still get to the chute and
singe it a little.  If you use enough, this won't happen,  BUT not
all rockets have enough space for that along with the requiisite
extra long, extra wide shock cord.

I like to put some dog barf in and use a square or two of the
Estes wadding next to the chute to give it a little extra protection,
sort of like a nomex chute protector is used in the larger rockets.
And there, I still use dog barf below the nomex.

As for the party paper, this stuff is all treated to be fire retardent.
Seems that party paper and birthday candles need this :)

I find the paper to be a little on the stiff side, but use it from time
to time.  I get the large sheets (versus the rolls) and cut it into
squares ala the Estes wadding.  Again, I like to mix it with
Estes wadding.  Because it's so stiff, it tends to take up more
space in the rocket, so instead of four squares of party paper,
I'll use two of it with two Estes squares (for example).

So, while there are alternatives, the Estes stuff if pretty good,
and not all that expensive when you consider the amount
of effort you put into using an alternate, and repairing singed
chutes.

Plus, if you're a real goober like me, you'll pick up the ejected
wadding and recycle it :)

HTH,
Doug
Rhhickok - 25 Feb 2004 17:06 GMT
With the blown cellulose insulation (dog barf), when I first started looking, I
couldn't find it at any Home Depots in my area, but the Lowes all seemed to
have it. So don't give up at if you don't find it at the first place.
"Cocoon" is the brand I usually find & a bag about the size of a bale of peat
moss should only cost you about $4 - $6 & could last years.  --  Richard
"finishing building the George Gassaway SST Concorde!!" Hickok
Jerry Irvine - 25 Feb 2004 18:40 GMT
In article
<f9c60d6263abe890440c044a5c5c1acb.39695@mygate.mailgate.org>,

> > I am fairly new to rocketry and have been using packets of recovery
> > wadding from estes. This is quite expensive where i live and i was
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> toilet paper treated with Borax seems outrageous, a bag usually
> lasts me a couple months or more, and I like the product.

Come on. Price aside, Estes wadding rocks.

Why pay less?

Jerry

Signature

Jerry Irvine, Box 1242, Claremont, California 91711 USA
Opinion, the whole thing. <mail to:01rocket@gte.net>
Please bring common sense back to rocketry administration.
Produce then publish.  http://www.usrockets.com
My articles valuable? Donate http://tinyurl.com/2hmgv

default - 25 Feb 2004 21:58 GMT
Hi Callum,   Depending on your locale, just use some of the native
vegitation.  I've used dandylion leaves, grass and other green leafy
vegetation.  Some care must be used in packing, and always make sure you
don't take any home and store it....  it rots.

steve

> I am fairly new to rocketry and have been using packets of recovery
> wadding from estes. This is quite expensive where i live and i was
> wondering if there are any alternatives to the shop bought packets.
> Please help
> Callum
Joel Corwith - 26 Feb 2004 01:35 GMT
> I am fairly new to rocketry and have been using packets of recovery
> wadding from estes. This is quite expensive where i live and i was
> wondering if there are any alternatives to the shop bought packets.
> Please help
> Callum

I used wadding when I flew many years ago.  When I got back into rocketry, I
was spoiled by the Aerotech kits I purchased.  With their baffle setup, I
could recover the rocket and on my way back to the flightline, pack the
chute and load a new motor.  Sumo was great for that (though it has a piston
configuration).  I've added chute protectors to the kids rockets when the
Estes chute gives out.  Both chute and protector come from Deb at Recovery
Technologies:
http://www.rocketparachutes.com/prices.html
Who's always at our local launches.   I also buy a length of Kevlar string
to use in place of the shockcord at the body attachment.  Then attach the
shock cord to the string.  When the shockcord finally breaks, you can easily
replace it.

I see ziplock baggies of cellulous insulation sold at launches for a buck or
2, but a bundle from HomeDepo is $6.  Buy 20 and you get to use the blower
free.  Then you can increase your ceiling insulation, and grab a handful or
2 on the way to the launch!

Joel. phx
Cliff Sojourner - 26 Feb 2004 06:03 GMT
> ... When I got back into rocketry, I
> was spoiled by the Aerotech kits I purchased.  With their baffle setup, I
> could recover the rocket and on my way back to the flightline, pack the
> chute and load a new motor.  Sumo was great for that (though it has a piston
> configuration).  

Joel, any advice on the Sumo?  we have one kit and I am wondering how
bad the piston system is.  (I've seen brand P pistons in action.)
Joel Corwith - 26 Feb 2004 15:54 GMT
> > ... When I got back into rocketry, I
> > was spoiled by the Aerotech kits I purchased.  With their baffle setup, I
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> Joel, any advice on the Sumo?  we have one kit and I am wondering how
> bad the piston system is.  (I've seen brand P pistons in action.)

I haven't had problems with P or A brand pistons.  But if you hadn't figure
out that phx is Phoenix AZ perhaps you might miss why that might be.  We
have zero humidity, well ok really around 15%.  We also don't have cold
weather, though it's rather chilly out there this morning (68ish).  Our club
launches with a miss-fire alley configuration, so the rocket is only out
there long enough to connect, check continuity, and walk to the card box at
the LCO table and back.  Usually I'm walking fast as he's already reading my
card.

Being as mine work, I'm not really qualified to tell you much about them
(failure modes).  Most of the comments I've read say to remove them, though
I'm guessing that's after a single failure, so they're probably not much
more qualified.  From what I understand, the gas pushes the piston which
pushes the chute and nose out.  So the nose still has to have the right fit,
but more importantly, the piston must have close tolerances to the body
tube.  Too close and it obviously isn't going to move, nor let the gases by.
Too loose and the gasses go around the piston, but is that a problem?
Issues with too close are swelling due to moisture (paper products),
contraction/expansion due to temperature and differing materials, buildup
from the ejection charge on the tubing.

So I push the piston in and out to see if it's rubbing on anything.  And
unlike most experiences I've read, I've never had to sand the piston to fit.
Then I'm cautious about bottoming it out.  On the Sumo, there's -just-
enough room for the piston and chute, though I believe that's because I used
a T-nut at the centering ring for the rail button.  Wrap of tape around the
motor to make sure the pressure goes another way (Mirage crash cause) and
off she goes.  Best I can do at this point is suggest a news group search on
'piston group:rec.models.rockets'  and/or with sumo in there.

Sorry can't be of more help regarding the piston, but as you said 'kit' and
not 'rocket' I'm assuming it's not built?  When I first get (or am deciding
to purchase) a rocket, I check out its review at:
www.rocketreviews.com
to see what others have experienced.  I know they copied an rmr post of mine
under one of the aerotech kit reviews which has generic comments for all the
kits.  Flip through those as almost all the construction is the same.  If my
comments are confusing, keep in mind they copied a block out of the rmr
post, so the witticism doesn't quite carry.

My Sumo (I keep typing suma4 for some reason) contacted a tree, ok really an
overgrown bush, and snapped a fin.  I'm in the process of grinding out the
old material and have a new fin to glue in.  Then I need to pink up the
color because it's too fuchsia.

Joel. phx

And when someone says pistons, I think motor pistons which have rings.  Has
anyone adapted go-kart piston rings to a rocket yet?
RayDunakin - 26 Feb 2004 03:03 GMT
<< I am fairly new to rocketry and have been using packets of recovery wadding
from estes. This is quite expensive where i live and i was wondering if there
are any alternatives to the shop bought packets. >>

A lot of folks use cellulose insulation from the hardware store. It's gray,
fluffy sort of stuff made from ground up newspapers or something like that.

I prefer lettuce myself, but that's not so cheap.
Gary - 26 Feb 2004 13:59 GMT
> I am fairly new to rocketry and have been using packets of recovery
> wadding from estes. This is quite expensive where i live and i was
> wondering if there are any alternatives to the shop bought packets.
> Please help
> Callum

Pistons and/or baffles; no wadding required.

A baffle which works well for me is an extended MMT tube with the
forward end plugged and a couple dozen small holes drilled in the MMT
wall. The gases vent sideways into the airframe ahead of the MMT CR. Two
balsa disks cut off along a chord and mounted 180 degrees to each other
forward of the MMT tube complete the baffle.

This really works well WITH a piston; the baffle traps, literally, all
the particulates and the airframe stays very clean where the piston
slides (forward of the balsa disks). I've used shock cord elastic for
the motor side piston strap without any heat problems using this baffle.

Little extra work, but no wadding and quick turn-around between flights.

Signature

Gary Bolles
NAR 82636

summum jus, summa injuria est

To contact me; bollesg at comcast dot net
http://home.comcast.net/~bollesg/rockets/rockets.html

Dwayne Surdu-Miller - 26 Feb 2004 17:11 GMT
Hi Callum,

Crepe paper party streamers make excellent wadding.  Streamers sold in
the United States and Canada are treated to be flame-resistant
(flame-retardant?) (by law, I believe).  They can be bought cheap in
good-sized rolls, from dollar stores, department stores, novelty shops
all over the place.

I'd like to try "dog barf" some time, but to my knowledge it's not
commercially available anywhere near where I live (in the middle of the
Canadian Great Plains).
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.