Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
General
ModelsRailroadsRockets
Radio Controlled
Air ModelsHelicoptersLand ModelsWater Models
ModelGeeks.com
Contact UsLink To UsSearch & Site Map

Model Forum / General / Railroads / November 2009



Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Heljan plans for 2010 onwards

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
John Turner - 18 Nov 2009 10:47 GMT
Heljan have just announced that the following items are planned / under
development with delivery scheduled from 2010 onwards:

4mm OO-SCALE

4-wheel railbuses (due 2010/11)
Waggon & Maschinen 4-wheel railbus (E79960-4)
Wickham 4-wheel railbus (SC79965-9)
Park Royal 4-wheel railbus (M79970-4)
AC Cars 4-wheel railbus (W79975-9)

Class 52 (in very small 2010 production runs)
D1000 Western Enterprise (desert sand)
D1001 Western Pathfinder (maroon)
D1012 Western Firebrand (maroon)
D1023 Western Fusilier (blue)

Class 23 'Baby Deltic' (4-character headcode model in blue & green - late
2010).

B&RCW 'Lion' prototype (2011 release).

7mm O-SCALE (2010/11)

Class 55 'Deltic' in post-1967 condition green & blue liveries

Regards,,
John Turner,
53A Models, Hull.
Fred Bear - 18 Nov 2009 11:21 GMT
> Heljan have just announced that the following items are planned /
> under development with delivery scheduled from 2010 onwards:
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> Park Royal 4-wheel railbus (M79970-4)
> AC Cars 4-wheel railbus (W79975-9)

Brilliant idea, I'm surprised no-one else has thought of it before to be
honest. I suspect that the basic mechanism for all 4 can be similar and
would suit a lot of green period modellers as a branch line on a larger
layout, or a small layout or even diorama. Plus being small, I suspect they
are likely to be on the affordable side compared to other options,
especially at the moment.
Fred X - 18 Nov 2009 15:09 GMT
> Heljan have just announced that the following items are planned / under
> development with delivery scheduled from 2010 onwards:
[quoted text clipped - 21 lines]
>
> Class 55 'Deltic' in post-1967 condition green & blue liveries

I knew about the Deltics and the Lion, but not about the railbuses!
Do they all have the same wheelbase I wonder as it seems strange that
they are making four different types? I guess Heljan have now decided
that they are going to concentrate on obscure prototypes that the big
boys are unlikely to produce.

Fred X
John Turner - 19 Nov 2009 10:15 GMT
> I knew about the Deltics and the Lion, but not about the railbuses!
> Do they all have the same wheelbase I wonder as it seems strange that
> they are making four different types?

The railbuses would probably only need one axle drive, so it would be a
relatively simple matter to vary the wheelsbase if they are/were different.

John.
Nigel Cliffe - 18 Nov 2009 18:47 GMT
> Heljan have just announced that the following items are planned /
> under development with delivery scheduled from 2010 onwards:
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> Park Royal 4-wheel railbus (M79970-4)
> AC Cars 4-wheel railbus (W79975-9)

This is vindictive actions by a big company !  I've only recently got the
Airfix 4-wheeled railbus running to my satisfaction, spent a fortune on DCC
decoder for it, etc..  And someone is going to have a much better detailed
one out of a box !

- Nigel

Signature

Nigel Cliffe,
Webmaster at http://www.2mm.org.uk/

Christopher A. Lee - 18 Nov 2009 19:16 GMT
>> Heljan have just announced that the following items are planned /
>> under development with delivery scheduled from 2010 onwards:
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
>decoder for it, etc..  And someone is going to have a much better detailed
>one out of a box !

I built the Airfix one but didn't motorise it. The only ones I saw and
rode in are the German ones on the Worth Valley. They were an order of
magnitude better than the Pacers.

But what I did ride in as a boy, were the horrible BUT 4-wheeled units
on the Wealdstone-Belmont shuttle.

>- Nigel
MartinS - 18 Nov 2009 19:28 GMT
> I built the Airfix one but didn't motorise it. The only ones I saw and
> rode in are the German ones on the Worth Valley. They were an order of
> magnitude better than the Pacers.

The Worth Valley is, I believe, limited to 25mph. I'm sure they'd be
pretty rough at Pacer speeds, e.g. on the 11-mile stretch between Shipley
and Leeds. I can remember in the early days of DMUs riding at the rear of
a lightly-loaded one doing 75mph on the Hull-Leeds run. Bouncy? Bouncy!

Signature

Martin S.

Robert Flint - 20 Nov 2009 09:23 GMT
>> I built the Airfix one but didn't motorise it. The only ones I saw and
>> rode in are the German ones on the Worth Valley. They were an order of
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> and Leeds. I can remember in the early days of DMUs riding at the rear of
> a lightly-loaded one doing 75mph on the Hull-Leeds run. Bouncy? Bouncy!

I used to travel from Leeds to Keighley regularly around the time the 142s
and 144s were introduced. I always thought they rode quite well at speed on
decently maintained track, the worst places being the junctions outside
Leeds and a particularly rough spot in the tunnel just before Shipley. I
also thought that the 144s felt more train than bus whilst the 142s were the
other way round, can't really explain why.

Beyond Skipton towards Carnforth, however, the ride could be 'lively' to say
the least!

ROB
Nigel Cliffe - 19 Nov 2009 11:04 GMT
>>> Heljan have just announced that the following items are planned /
>>> under development with delivery scheduled from 2010 onwards:
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> I built the Airfix one but didn't motorise it. The only ones I saw and
> rode in are the German ones on the Worth Valley.

Motorising the Airfix for me has been an exercise in cost explosions. It
resembles a government computer project !

Railbus, cost at most £3. Motorising kit and interior kit (Branchlines),
probable cost circa £35, bought those bits ages ago.  DCC chips (Lenz Gold
and PM1 power module) £70.  My £3 Airfix kit has come in at about £110.
But it does run well and the PM1 guarantees it doesn't stall which is
necessary for a four wheeled vehicle running an automatic shuttle service.

Prototype anecdotes:

I think at preserved line speeds they ride quite well, but that's ~25mph. I
don't think they will ride so well at 50mph.

When a teenager I occaisionally travelled to the railway at Sherringham,
Norfolk, for working parties.

One year a Keighley driver was there to drive the N.Norfolk's service
railbus(*).  Unfortunately, he forgot the line rule about not stopping this
particular railbus' engine at lunchtime as the battery charging from the
engine was suspect.  My job for the rest of the day was supervising several
hundred feet of extension cable and a hefty battery charger. Initially
enough to get to the railbus to start it, then at station stops a bit more
charge to help the gearbox along.   I think it had most of the gears back by
the end of the afternoon.
Thinking back, I wonder if the intermediate charges had much effect on the
battery compared to charging off the engine, but it was obviously needed for
the initial starting.

It made a welcome change from painting wagon solebars or shovelling ballast
!

(* the NN had two at the time, one in normal service, and the other
exquisitly restored and only used with very trusted passengers).

- Nigel

Signature

Nigel Cliffe,
Webmaster at http://www.2mm.org.uk/

MartinS - 18 Nov 2009 19:23 GMT
>> Heljan have just announced that the following items are planned /
>> under development with delivery scheduled from 2010 onwards:
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
> fortune on DCC decoder for it, etc..  And someone is going to have a
> much better detailed one out of a box !

LOL! It's always the way! I'd just built up my fleet of tender-drive
Hornby locos and associated rolling stock in the 1990s when the new
superdetailed models were announced.

I've had an Airfix/Dapol railbus kit for years but have never assembled
it. Motorising kits are (or used to be) available.

Signature

Martin S.

simon - 18 Nov 2009 21:35 GMT
>>> Heljan have just announced that the following items are planned /
>>> under development with delivery scheduled from 2010 onwards:
[quoted text clipped - 18 lines]
> I've had an Airfix/Dapol railbus kit for years but have never assembled
> it. Motorising kits are (or used to be) available.

I cant help buying 4F's despite it being the most likely to be upgraded
soon. Latest was an almost completed Wills kit for GBP25, but as its got
Romford wheels tis worth that for them alone.

Cheers,
Simon
Nigel Cliffe - 19 Nov 2009 11:06 GMT
>>> Heljan have just announced that the following items are planned /
>>> under development with delivery scheduled from 2010 onwards:
[quoted text clipped - 13 lines]
>
> LOL! It's always the way!

I've just had an idea...
I'm going to find a Heljan loco box and put the Airfix one in that.  Watch
the collectors scream at me to sell the "pre-release" example :-)

- Nigel

Signature

Nigel Cliffe,
Webmaster at http://www.2mm.org.uk/

Jerry - 19 Nov 2009 20:22 GMT
<snip>

: I've just had an idea...
: I'm going to find a Heljan loco box and put the Airfix one in that.  Watch
: the collectors scream at me to sell the "pre-release" example
:-)

What, and have Pete Water(works)man accuse Heljan of intellectual
property theft?!...
Chris Wilson - 18 Nov 2009 23:09 GMT
>> Heljan have just announced that the following items are planned /
>> under development with delivery scheduled from 2010 onwards:
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
> fortune on DCC decoder for it, etc..  And someone is going to have a
> much better detailed one out of a box !

In which case is there any chance you can scratch build some L&Y engines
over the next 12 months? :-)

Signature

All the best,

Chris

John Turner - 19 Nov 2009 10:16 GMT
> In which case is there any chance you can scratch build some L&Y engines
> over the next 12 months? :-)

Or even better, some former North Eastern prototypes please.

John.
simon - 19 Nov 2009 10:47 GMT
>> In which case is there any chance you can scratch build some L&Y engines
>> over the next 12 months? :-)
>
> Or even better, some former North Eastern prototypes please.
>
> John.

Midland or LNWR pre-group over here...

Cheers,
Simon
Andrew Robert Breen - 19 Nov 2009 11:35 GMT
>>> In which case is there any chance you can scratch build some L&Y engines
>>> over the next 12 months? :-)
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
>>
>Midland or LNWR pre-group over here...

What's missing - for pretty well every railway - is the ubiquitous 0-6-0
tender engine (the GW is, IIRC, the only one to be reasonably covered,
with the - rather elderly- Dean Goods from Hornby: the likes of 4Fs, Q1s
and J39s being rather large - and late - to really cut it).

So, as a starter?

NER: C/C1 (J21) - they don't get more ubiquitous than those things..
L&NW: Coal engine or Cauliflower (Special DX proably too much to ask.. ;)
Midland: Kirtley, though a Johnson engine would probably be easier to
model..
L&SW: Adams 700 (that would make the western-section SR entirely
modellable with RTR only, something that no pre-nationalisation railway is
at present..[1])

other examples will no doubt occur (Highland / Caledonian Jumbos, for
example..), but those would serve. There are any numbr of NER lines you
could quite happily run with nothing but Cs..

[1] Well, you'd need to find a green N class mogul: Bachmann don't seem to
do 'em in anything other than BR black now. Why?

Signature

Andy Breen ~     Not speaking on behalf of the University of Wales, Aberystwyth
        Feng Shui: an ancient oriental art for extracting
        money from the gullible (Martin Sinclair)

simon - 20 Nov 2009 00:17 GMT
>>>> In which case is there any chance you can scratch build some L&Y
>>>> engines
[quoted text clipped - 27 lines]
> [1] Well, you'd need to find a green N class mogul: Bachmann don't seem to
> do 'em in anything other than BR black now. Why?

Not the Cauliflower already done a GEM one - tis nice though, one of my
favourites. Coal and Johnson engines ok as only done tanks so far.
Understand about 4F's but might be safer if they worked back from say 1930's
so that periods could be modelled by the addition of a few engines rather
than requiring a complete set.

Cheers,
Simon
Nigel Cliffe - 19 Nov 2009 10:50 GMT
>>> Heljan have just announced that the following items are planned /
>>> under development with delivery scheduled from 2010 onwards:
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> In which case is there any chance you can scratch build some L&Y
> engines over the next 12 months? :-)

I've a L&Y battery electric finished apart from the lining (daunting
prospect, probably going to learn print-your-own decals for this job) and
lettering.  Its from the High Level kit, with various electronic gizmos
added.   I think those are sufficiently obscure to be safe !

- Nigel

Signature

Nigel Cliffe,
Webmaster at http://www.2mm.org.uk/

Paul Boyd - 19 Nov 2009 19:08 GMT
> I've a L&Y battery electric finished apart from the lining (daunting
> prospect, probably going to learn print-your-own decals for this job) and
> lettering.  Its from the High Level kit, with various electronic gizmos
> added.   I think those are sufficiently obscure to be safe !

Ditto, without the electronic gizmos.  I didn't spring this one though...

Printing your own decals is a hobby in itself.  Well, it is with an Alps
printer like what I've got. <smug mode off>  I never got on with inkjet
decals.  Actually, with a decent bow pen lining with that is far more
satisfying.  I was lucky enough to get a second hand Kern bowpen off
eBay, and the difference in using that compared to the sort of bowpen
you get in the typical compass sets from WH Smith is incredible.  With
just a little practise I was able to get three distinct lines within a
millimetre - that's about 0.2mm line with 0.2mm gap between them.  I
can't get that on the Alps!

Signature

Paul Boyd
http://www.paul-boyd.me.uk/

MartinS - 19 Nov 2009 21:02 GMT
>> I've a L&Y battery electric finished apart from the lining (daunting
>> prospect, probably going to learn print-your-own decals for this job)
[quoted text clipped - 13 lines]
> distinct lines within a millimetre - that's about 0.2mm line with
> 0.2mm gap between them.  I can't get that on the Alps!

Unfortunately the ALPS is old technology, but supposedly prints 600dpi.

http://www.pcpro.co.uk/reviews/printers/1711/alps-md-1000

Date reviewed: 1 October 1997.

Signature

Martin S.

Paul Boyd - 19 Nov 2009 22:15 GMT
> Unfortunately the ALPS is old technology, but supposedly prints 600dpi.

It is old technology, but there is still a thriving user base.  There
are still people using these for commercial purposes, including at least
a couple producing model railway decals.  The wise have a spare stock of
printers and a healthy stock of ribbons to go with them.  I have a "new"
MD-1000 in the garage as my spare, with an MD-1300 sitting about 1 foot
from my left hand as I type.  I felt compelled to try printing my own
decals after being ripped off by a decal maker in North Wales.

It's shame the Alps printers are obsolete, but the inkjet market
overtook them and they just couldn't keep up.  The photo printing
quality is bloody awful!

Signature

Paul Boyd
http://www.paul-boyd.me.uk/

cctransuk - 23 Nov 2009 16:19 GMT
> > Unfortunately the ALPS is old technology, but supposedly prints 600dpi.
>
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> --
> Paul Boydhttp://www.paul-boyd.me.uk/

Paul will know this but, for the benefit of the group, be aware that
you can still (just) purchase Alps printers - see http://www.alps-supplies.com/

My own transfer range - http://www.cctrans.freeserve.co.uk/products.htm
- are printed on an Alps MD1000. (I do have several spare printers in
stock)!

Regards,
John Isherwood.
Greg.Procter - 25 Nov 2009 03:05 GMT
>>> Heljan have just announced that the following items are planned /
>>> under development with delivery scheduled from 2010 onwards:
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> In which case is there any chance you can scratch build some L&Y engines
> over the next 12 months? :-)

Which ones do you want?
I'm working away at an L&Y Radial 2-4-2t at the moment, preparing a  
drawing to build from.
Following that, I'd like to do a High-Flyer and a goods loco.

Having previously built European and New Zealand models, I'm realizing I  
don't know
some things about British locos that are probably breed into British  
modellers - an
off the top of my head example might be how thick the vertical lamp irons  
should be.

I could do with having an L&Y modeller to bounce my drawings off to spot  
the mistakes.

Loco will be milled brass, so I could offer a set of parts at cost price  
in exchange.

Regards,
Greg.P.
NZ
John Turner - 25 Nov 2009 08:28 GMT
> I could do with having an L&Y modeller to bounce my drawings off to spot
> the mistakes.

I assume there's an L&Y Yahoo email list, but failing that you could try:

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/lmsreg/

There are some extremely knowledgeable members on there.

John.
Chris Wilson - 25 Nov 2009 21:25 GMT
>> I could do with having an L&Y modeller to bounce my drawings off to
>> spot the mistakes.
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
>
> There are some extremely knowledgeable members on there.

There's also the L&Y society - which I keep meaning to join myself. Oh and
like Greg I'm also toying with the idea of building the iconic L&Y 2-4-2T.

Signature

All the best,

Chris

Greg.Procter - 26 Nov 2009 07:04 GMT
>>> I could do with having an L&Y modeller to bounce my drawings off to
>>> spot the mistakes.
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
> like Greg I'm also toying with the idea of building the iconic L&Y  
> 2-4-2T.

I've received a lot of info from the L&Y society - I'd suggest it would be  
worth joining -
but how many societies can one join???

Greg.P.
NZ
simon - 26 Nov 2009 21:22 GMT
>>>> I could do with having an L&Y modeller to bounce my drawings off to
>>>> spot the mistakes.
[quoted text clipped - 17 lines]
> Greg.P.
> NZ

There are a few societies that sometimes think would benefit from
membership, but think its very important that I should be able to contribute
as well as recieve info. Dont feel ready to contribute to some of better
ones (eg LMS) so not joined. Trouble with one or 2 others (esp professional)
is there seems to be a core membership who are really into it and the others
just making up the numbers (and paying fees).
Nothing here is meant as critisizing any societies, just criteria I use to
decide if wish to join.

cheers,
Simon
Greg.Procter - 27 Nov 2009 01:33 GMT
>>>>> I could do with having an L&Y modeller to bounce my drawings off to
>>>>> spot the mistakes.
[quoted text clipped - 29 lines]
> cheers,
> Simon

Hi Simon,
I'm mostly German HO, followed by New Zealand Railways G gauge and am just
building an L&Y loco because I want one (or more)
I have sub-collections of Maerklin and Trix Twin/Trix Express.

I can't join every relevant society.

Regards,
Greg.P.

Signature

Using Opera's revolutionary e-mail client: http://www.opera.com/mail/

simon - 27 Nov 2009 11:18 GMT
>>>>>> I could do with having an L&Y modeller to bounce my drawings off to
>>>>>> spot the mistakes.
[quoted text clipped - 39 lines]
> Regards,
> Greg.P.

Wouldnt mind the odd L&Y myself but as interested in LMS - LNWR and Midland
there are so many kits and so little time (only 24 hours in a day :-)).
Looks like got to get job in london so with commuting present phase of kit
building may be curtailed although could do some fettling on the train !
Been a good run though, got quite a few done and learnt lots !

Saw some Maerklin  from early 60's the other day that had been in someones
loft for many years. Now understand just how good theyre models were at that
time - fascinating.

Cheers,
Simon
David Littlewood - 27 Nov 2009 12:35 GMT
>Wouldnt mind the odd L&Y myself but as interested in LMS - LNWR and
>Midland there are so many kits and so little time (only 24 hours in a
>day :-)). Looks like got to get job in london so with commuting present
>phase of kit building may be curtailed although could do some fettling
>on the train !

Not on any of the London commuter trains I have been on! Unless you
travel very much off-peak, you are lucky to get a seat.

David
Signature

David Littlewood

simon - 27 Nov 2009 16:27 GMT
>>Wouldnt mind the odd L&Y myself but as interested in LMS - LNWR and
>>Midland there are so many kits and so little time (only 24 hours in a day
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
>
> David

Even Inter-city trains, Nuneaton - Euston ?
Just visited Nuneaton station for first time in 8 years, what the heck is
the new bit for - not a straight line in the structures, was that
intentional.

Cheers,
Simon
Greg.Procter - 30 Nov 2009 01:18 GMT
>>>>>>> I could do with having an L&Y modeller to bounce my drawings off to
>>>>>>> spot the mistakes.
[quoted text clipped - 57 lines]
> Cheers,
> Simon

Make yourself a "travelling workbench" needs only to be long enough to
carry a 150mm rule, 2-3 files, a craft knife, pinvice, a few drill bits
etc and a few film cannisters for small components. Ohh, an engineers  
square.
The box needs a top that can be cut on (plywood with one of those green
uncutable surfaces glued on with contact cement.
A small rigid chocolate box  for your models and some photocopies of
plans/articles.
When it's boiled down you really don't need much to do 95% of your  
modelling :-)

Greg.P.
simon - 30 Nov 2009 14:01 GMT
>>>>>>>> I could do with having an L&Y modeller to bounce my drawings off to
>>>>>>>> spot the mistakes.
[quoted text clipped - 70 lines]
>
> Greg.P.

Nice idea, plant to do some of fiddly, time consuming, none critical  jobs
like making loco steps out of brass. Make mess then can start again. Succeed
and its a bonus.

Cheers,
Simon
John Turner - 27 Nov 2009 09:02 GMT
> There are a few societies that sometimes think would benefit from
> membership, but think its very important that I should be able to
> contribute as well as recieve info. Dont feel ready to contribute to some
> of better ones (eg LMS) so not joined.

But you can join their email list (free of any charge) without being a
member of the society!  Contribution to same is a voluntary thing.  I don't
consider myself terribly knowledgeable about the history of the LMS, but I
have learned a lot from the members' exchange of emails and contributed in a
small way.

John.
simon - 27 Nov 2009 10:58 GMT
>> There are a few societies that sometimes think would benefit from
>> membership, but think its very important that I should be able to
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
>
> John.
Thanks for that John, will re-visit.

Cheers,
Simon
Fred Bear - 30 Nov 2009 10:00 GMT
>> There are a few societies that sometimes think would benefit from
>> membership, but think its very important that I should be able to
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
>
> John.

The other problem with not joining societies because you don't feel
knowledgeable enough to contribute is the risk of noone for the group to
pass knowledge onto and therefore the risk of such knowledge dying with the
members of the group. Whilst it's dangerous to assume, I would speculate
based on model railway groups I've seen or been involved with is that the
majority of such groups tend to be older members. I would also suspect the
knowledgeable chaps in groups specialising in pre grouping or even grouping
would be people who were closer to the time specialised in than most of the
rest of us. Whilst the web has made it easier to share and publish
knowledge cheaply for posterity, most people of all age groups seem unaware
of how easy it really is and get scared off. Given how difficult it is to
publish on paper, the best way of ensuring continuance of knowledge is word
of mouth - to people willing to soak up as much info as possible. Even
better if it's someone who can then publish the knowledge for everyone's
benefit!

Seriously, if you're interested in the area, then I would strongly suggest
letting your lack of knowledge be a strength to the group in being willing
to learn as much of your chosen interest as possible and willing to pass
on.

Best of luck!
Alistair Wright - 27 Nov 2009 11:36 GMT
> Dont feel ready to contribute to some of better ones (eg LMS) so not
> joined.

Err, you don't 'join' the LMS Society I'm afraid - you wait till you are
'invited'. This only happens if you have a contribution to make to the
research and modelling activities. The LMSS realised on day one that there
were too many people who just want to take what they can get and put nothing
in but their subs so we made it a 'closed' society to that group. On the
other hand if you have a genuine contribution to make to the recording and
modelling of the LMS (doing research, writing articles, books, producing
kits etc) you will be welcomed into the group. At the moment we have about
50+ members and it looks like staying around that number. We justify this
behaviour by giving out information and advice to any outsiders who ask
questions or need to see drawings, photographs, etc. We have a website which
gives details of our services. Members have published hundreds of books and
thousands of articles in the 46 year history of the LMS Society. We meet as
a society twice a year in LMS locations usually for a weekend of talks and
data exchange.

Alistair Wright
LMS Soc Coaching stock archivist
simon - 27 Nov 2009 16:32 GMT
>> Dont feel ready to contribute to some of better ones (eg LMS) so not
>> joined.
[quoted text clipped - 17 lines]
> Alistair Wright
> LMS Soc Coaching stock archivist

This is exactly how it should be in the others I described, like it. One day
may qualify, who knows. If they dont let me in then will start my own :-)
But I do support the society by buying the journal - absolutely wonderful
publication.

Cheers,
Simon
Alistair Wright - 28 Nov 2009 10:48 GMT
">>
> This is exactly how it should be in the others I described, like it. One
> day may qualify, who knows. If they dont let me in then will start my own
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> Cheers,
> Simon
Well I doubt any of the other outfits can, or would, operate like the LMSS.
BTW you can 'ask' to join and if you do you will be invited to make your
case, and if it's good enough, get a chance to attend a meeting where you
will be 'looked at' by the members. Sounds a bit elitist (what's wrong with
that?) but it keeps the Society at the forefront of railway societies.
That's how I joined. Only one person has ever been black-balled and he was a
known notorious troublemaker in the S4 Society. Glad you like the Journal -
it makes my point - all these guys are 'contributors' to the hobby not
passive collectors of magazines and box emptiers.

Maybe see you sometime,

Alistair
simon - 28 Nov 2009 21:01 GMT
> ">>
>> This is exactly how it should be in the others I described, like it. One
[quoted text clipped - 17 lines]
>
> Alistair
Thanks, absolutely nothing wrong with the apparent elitist slant or the aims
of the group. Maybe one day in many years time might be ready to consider.
In the meantime will continue to obtain and make use of the output.

Cheers,
Simon
Paul Boyd - 29 Nov 2009 13:54 GMT
> Thanks, absolutely nothing wrong with the apparent elitist slant...

Yet this is the very thing that many of the finescale societies are
accused of, where it is deemed to be A Bad Thing.

Double standards, methinks.

Signature

Paul Boyd
http://www.paul-boyd.me.uk/

simon - 29 Nov 2009 22:22 GMT
>> Thanks, absolutely nothing wrong with the apparent elitist slant...
>
> Yet this is the very thing that many of the finescale societies are
> accused of, where it is deemed to be A Bad Thing.
>
> Double standards, methinks.

Can understand why that seems so but it isnt the same. Difficult to explain,
but heres a start on my opinion. They dont give the impression that they are
doing something that makes them better than anyone else. They are happy to
share the end result of their researches with anyone else. Anyone who is
willing able to put in the same effort is wellcome. The numbers are kept low
so that they dont get swamped. They are open and honest about these aims.

Cheers,
Simon
Jerry - 30 Nov 2009 09:37 GMT
: >> Thanks, absolutely nothing wrong with the apparent elitist slant...
: >
: > Yet this is the very thing that many of the finescale societies are
: > accused of, where it is deemed to be A Bad Thing.
: >
: > Double standards, methinks.

Chalk and cheese more like...

: Can understand why that seems so but it isnt the same. Difficult to explain,
: but heres a start on my opinion. They dont give the impression that they are
: doing something that makes them better than anyone else. They are happy to
: share the end result of their researches with anyone else. Anyone who is
: willing able to put in the same effort is wellcome. The numbers are kept low
: so that they dont get swamped. They are open and honest about these aims.

Indeed, the LMSS is a society that (at least originally) was set
up to **Promote the LMS** (in the face of overwhelming support of
all things Swindon and the west country) - someone more
interested in the GWR would not have been very welcome, in a
similar vain, the EM and P4 societies were set up to **promote
fine scale modelling** - someone more interested in clipping
together Triang 'Super4' track on the carpet and playing trains
with stock using road-roller style wheels and ploughs for flanges
would not have been made very welcome either. any of the above
societies need to be 'elitist', if they were not they could soon
become swamped and diluted in their aims, it could also be said
that both the Triang and the Hornby(-Duble0) societies are
elitist in their own ways too...
Paul Boyd - 30 Nov 2009 18:28 GMT
> They dont give the impression
> that they are doing something that makes them better than anyone else.
> They are happy to share the end result of their researches with anyone
> else. Anyone who is willing able to put in the same effort is wellcome.

That sums up most S4 Society and EMGS members, except that you don't
need to put in the same effort as others to be welcome!  Most of us are
more than willing to show others how to do things and share research -
that's what it's all about!  I think in the past there were people who
just liked to show off rather than educate and pass on skills, but those
days have long gone.  Perhaps the stigma has remained.

To take Jerry's point, would the LMSS really make a GWR enthusiast
unwelcome?  What about someone who wants to learn more about the LMS?
It sounds like you need to know enough to contribute before you're
allowed to even join.  That can't be right, surely?  The societies I
mentioned above would be more than welcoming to someone who just wanted
to clip Super-4 track together, or even OO modellers :-)

Signature

Paul Boyd
http://www.paul-boyd.me.uk/

Jerry - 30 Nov 2009 20:49 GMT
: > They dont give the impression
: > that they are doing something that makes them better than anyone else.
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
: more than willing to show others how to do things and share research -
: that's what it's all about!

Not all, I well remember talking to a EMGS member who I had been
directed towards (at a EXPO EM meeting), with the suggestion that
he would be more than welcome to share his research (reasonable
expenses paid, postage etc, and all that) on a specific station,
only to be told by him that he would never share his research
because he might one day want to exhibit his layout - sorry to
say that I walked away muttering things that perhaps I should not
have, but it did leave a bitter taste in the mouth, I went on to
join the P4 society rather than renew my subs - and no I did not
join the EMGS to be a 'research leach'...

 I think in the past there were people who
: just liked to show off rather than educate and pass on skills, but those
: days have long gone.  Perhaps the stigma has remained.

Hmm, perhaps I was just unlucky!

: To take Jerry's point, would the LMSS really make a GWR enthusiast
: unwelcome?  What about someone who wants to learn more about the LMS?

I did say *more interested*, obviously if someone was as (or
becoming) interested in the LMS as the GWR I'm sure that they
would be more than welcome, especially if the person already had
a proven ability to contribute - how ever that might be.

: It sounds like you need to know enough to contribute before you're
: allowed to even join.  That can't be right, surely?

Why, if that is what the society is about?!

The societies I
: mentioned above would be more than welcoming to someone who just wanted
: to clip Super-4 track together, or even OO modellers :-)

But not if they then tried to steer the society in a different
direction, which by definition they would do if they started to
become the majority within a *specialist* society, obviously
there are more general societies that one could become members of
(such as "The Model Railway Club" or the HMRS etc.) were one
would add to the scope of the society regardless of interests.
simon - 30 Nov 2009 23:07 GMT
>> They dont give the impression that they are doing something that makes
>> them better than anyone else. They are happy to share the end result of
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> would be more than welcoming to someone who just wanted to clip Super-4
> track together, or even OO modellers :-)

But they publish journals that are the output from their research and
available to anyone that wishes to buy them.
They are no different to any professional society who requires a minimum
education standard or experience.

Cheers,
Simon
simon g - 20 Nov 2009 11:53 GMT
I am Wondering if Heljan will have pre production samples at the NEC in
Birmingham this weekend, and also what Dapol, Hornby, and Bachmann will
bring, any ideas anyone ?
Simon G
> Heljan have just announced that the following items are planned / under
> development with delivery scheduled from 2010 onwards:
[quoted text clipped - 24 lines]
> Regards,,
> John Turner,
John Turner - 20 Nov 2009 13:36 GMT
>I am Wondering if Heljan will have pre production samples at the NEC in
>Birmingham this weekend, and also what Dapol, Hornby, and Bachmann will
>bring, any ideas anyone ?

Ah!  I can help with Bachmann new releases.

This week we've received totally new models as follows:

31-425 4-CEP BR(SR) EMU in plain green livery and
31-975 BR Standard 3MT 2-6-2T 82029 (black/early crest)

John.
chorleydnc@hotmail.com - 23 Nov 2009 12:42 GMT
> "simon g"  wrote
>
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
>
> John.

Oh great a 4-CEP... according to recent BBC website photos they can be
found anywhere on the british railway system and in many foreign
countries.

(:-))

David
Fred X - 23 Nov 2009 15:09 GMT
>> >I am Wondering if Heljan will have pre production samples at the NEC in
>> >Birmingham this weekend, and also what Dapol, Hornby, and Bachmann will
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> found anywhere on the british railway system and in many foreign
> countries.

AKA North Of Watford. :)

Fred X
beamends - 23 Nov 2009 15:30 GMT
>> "simon g"  wrote
>>
[quoted text clipped - 18 lines]
>
> David

And in operating theatres world wide ;-)

Cheers
Richard

Signature

I have become...............comfortably numb

David Jackson - 23 Nov 2009 16:36 GMT
The message <iKOdnaxAdMYGN5fWnZ2dnUVZ8h2dnZ2d@bt.com>
from beamends <sales@beamends-lrspares.co.uk> contains these words:

> > Oh great a 4-CEP... according to recent BBC website photos they can be
> > found anywhere on the british railway system and in many foreign
> > countries.

> And in operating theatres world wide ;-)

But only in pairs.

Signature

Dave,                                    
Frodsham
http://dave-jackson.fotopic.net

Greg.Procter - 23 Nov 2009 21:51 GMT
>>> "simon g"  wrote
>>>
[quoted text clipped - 20 lines]
>
> And in operating theatres world wide ;-)

That wouldn't leave much space for the anaethetist, nor the equipment  
trolley!
MartinS - 23 Nov 2009 17:35 GMT
>> "simon g"  wrote
>>
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
>
> (:-))

What does the BBC know? And why is it on a BBC website anyway?

Signature

Martin S.

airsmoothed - 24 Nov 2009 14:45 GMT
> "chorley...@hotmail.com" <chorley...@gmail.com> wrote:
> >> "simon g"  wrote
[quoted text clipped - 22 lines]
>
> - Show quoted text -

I assume the comment was alluding to the fact that the BBC website
tends to use a stock photo of a 1st gen 3rd. rail electric to
illustrate any rail related news story worldwide ;-)
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2012 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.